Unit for Preventive Nutrition, Department of Biosciences and Nutrition, Karolinska Institutet, 14157 Huddinge, Sweden.
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2009 Dec 11;6:91. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-6-91.
The stability of dietary habits through various life-stages is not well understood. A better understanding of the tracking of diet over time could have implications for health promotion as well as for the planning of nutritional epidemiology studies. We examined the stability of dietary intakes of children and adolescents over six years.
As part of the European Youth Heart Study, in 1998-9, a 24-h dietary recall was performed on over one thousand 9- and 15-year-olds in Sweden. In 2004-5, 40% returned to the follow-up study. These 452 subjects (273 15- and 179 21-year-olds) were assigned to age- and gender-specific tertiles of intakes of food groups, energy, selected nutrients and energy density (low, mid and high) at each time point. The agreement between the classification of subjects into tertiles at both time points was examined using Cohen's weighted kappa and other stability coefficients. We included a dropout analysis and considered the effect that energy mis-reporting might have on our results.
Fair tracking was seen between childhood and adolescence for the milk, fil and yoghurt food group (kappa = 0.30), and between adolescence and young adulthood for fruit (kappa = 0.24). Slight tracking was observed for most other food groups and fair to slight tracking for all nutrients studied. Only membership of the high milk, fil and yoghurt tertile could be predicted from membership at baseline, in children. Excluding potential energy mis-reporters did not affect the results.
Despite the long time between data collections, and the method of dietary data collection used, evidence for slight tracking was observed for most food groups and nutrients over these six years.
不同生命阶段饮食习惯的稳定性尚未得到充分理解。更好地了解饮食随时间的追踪情况,既可以促进健康,也可以为营养流行病学研究的规划提供依据。我们研究了儿童和青少年在六年期间的饮食摄入的稳定性。
作为欧洲青年心脏研究的一部分,在 1998 年至 1999 年,瑞典对一千多名 9 岁和 15 岁的青少年进行了 24 小时饮食回忆。2004 年至 2005 年,40%的人返回参加随访研究。这些 452 名受试者(273 名 15 岁和 179 名 21 岁)根据每个时间点的食物组、能量、选定营养素和能量密度(低、中、高)的摄入量,被分配到年龄和性别特异性三分位数。使用 Cohen 的加权 kappa 和其他稳定性系数来检查在两个时间点将受试者分类为三分位数的一致性。我们进行了辍学分析,并考虑了能量报告错误可能对我们结果的影响。
在儿童期和青春期之间,牛奶、鱼类和酸奶食物组的跟踪情况良好(kappa = 0.30),在青春期和青年期之间,水果的跟踪情况良好(kappa = 0.24)。对于大多数其他食物组,观察到了轻微的跟踪,对于所有研究的营养素,跟踪情况为良好至轻微。只有在儿童期属于高牛奶、鱼类和酸奶三分位数的人群,才能从基线时的成员身份预测。排除潜在的能量报告错误并不影响结果。
尽管两次数据收集之间的时间很长,并且使用了饮食数据收集方法,但在这六年中,大多数食物组和营养素的跟踪情况都显示出轻微的趋势。