Baker Rachel E, Bradlow Ann R
Department of Linguistics, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA.
Lang Speech. 2009;52(Pt 4):391-413. doi: 10.1177/0023830909336575.
This article examines how probability (lexical frequency and previous mention), speech style, and prosody affect word duration, and how these factors interact. Participants read controlled materials in clear and plain speech styles. As expected, more probable words (higher frequencies and clear speech second mentions) were significantly shorter than less probable words, and lexical frequency words in plain speech were significantly shorter than those in clear speech. Interestingly, we found second mention reduction effects in both clear and second mention plain speech, indicating that while clear speech is hyper-articulated, this reduction hyper-articulation does not override probabilistic effects on duration. We also found an interaction between mention and frequency, but only in plain speech. High frequency words allowed more second mention reduction than low frequency words in plain speech, revealing a tendency to hypo-articulate as much as possible when all factors support it. Finally, we found that first mentions were more likely to be accented than second mentions. However, when these differences in accent likelihood were controlled, a significant second mention reduction effect remained. This supports the concept of a direct link between probability and duration, rather than a relationship solely mediated by prosodic prominence.
本文探讨了概率(词汇频率和前文提及)、言语风格和韵律如何影响单词时长,以及这些因素之间如何相互作用。参与者以清晰平实的言语风格阅读对照材料。正如预期的那样,更具概率的单词(更高频率以及在清晰言语中的第二次提及)明显比概率较低的单词短,并且平实言语中的词汇频率单词比清晰言语中的明显更短。有趣的是,我们在清晰言语和第二次提及的平实言语中都发现了第二次提及减少效应,这表明虽然清晰言语发音过度,但这种减少的过度发音并未凌驾于对时长的概率影响之上。我们还发现提及和频率之间存在相互作用,但仅在平实言语中。在平实言语中,高频单词比低频单词允许更多的第二次提及减少,这揭示了在所有因素都支持的情况下尽可能少发音的一种趋势。最后,我们发现首次提及比第二次提及更有可能带有重音。然而,当这些重音可能性的差异得到控制时,显著的第二次提及减少效应仍然存在。这支持了概率与时长之间存在直接联系的概念,而不是仅由韵律突出介导的关系。