George Asha, Menotti Elaine P, Rivera Dixmer, Montes Irma, Reyes Carmen Mar, Marsh David R
Community Based Approaches, Policy and Evidence Unit, Health Section, Programme Division, UNICEF, Three UN Plaza H-8, New York, NY 10017, USA.
J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2009;20(4 Suppl):99-115. doi: 10.1353/hpu.0.0205.
While social factors broadly determine health outcomes, strategic health workforce innovations such as community case management (CCM) can redress social inequalities in access to health care. Community case management enables trained health workers to assess children, diagnose common childhood infections, administer medicines, and monitor life-saving treatment in the poor, remote communities where they reside. This article reports on research that combined focus group discussions and key informant interviews to examine the perceptions of multiple stakeholders, with monitoring data, in order to assess programmatic results, limitations, and lessons learned in implementing CCM in Nicaragua. We found that CCM increases the use of curative services by poor children with pneumonia, diarrhea, or dysentery by five to six-fold over facility-based services. Apart from dramatically increasing geographic access to treatment for underserved groups, our qualitative research suggests that Nicaragua's CCM model also addresses the managerial challenges and social relations that underpin good quality of care, care-giver knowledge and awareness, and community mobilization, all health system-strengthening factors that are central to equitably and effectively improving child health. While our findings are promising, we suggest areas for further operational research to strengthen CCM program learning and functioning.
虽然社会因素广泛决定健康结果,但诸如社区病例管理(CCM)等战略性卫生人力创新措施能够纠正获得医疗保健方面的社会不平等现象。社区病例管理使经过培训的卫生工作者能够对儿童进行评估、诊断常见的儿童感染、给药,并在他们所居住的贫困偏远社区监测挽救生命的治疗。本文报告了一项研究,该研究结合焦点小组讨论和关键信息人访谈,以研究多个利益相关者的看法,并结合监测数据,以便评估在尼加拉瓜实施社区病例管理的方案成果、局限性和经验教训。我们发现,与基于医疗机构的服务相比,社区病例管理使患有肺炎、腹泻或痢疾的贫困儿童使用治疗性服务的比例提高了五到六倍。除了显著增加服务不足群体获得治疗的地理可及性之外,我们的定性研究表明,尼加拉瓜的社区病例管理模式还解决了支撑优质护理、护理人员知识和意识以及社区动员的管理挑战和社会关系问题,所有这些都是加强卫生系统的因素,对于公平有效地改善儿童健康至关重要。虽然我们的研究结果很有前景,但我们建议开展进一步的操作性研究,以加强社区病例管理项目的学习和运作。