Group Health Research Institute, Seattle, Washington 98101, USA.
Depress Anxiety. 2010 May;27(5):441-50. doi: 10.1002/da.20671.
Although massage is one of the most popular complementary and alternative medical (CAM) treatments for anxiety, its effectiveness has never been rigorously evaluated for a diagnosed anxiety disorder. This study evaluates the effectiveness of therapeutic massage for persons with generalized anxiety disorder (GAD).
Sixty-eight persons with GAD were randomized to therapeutic massage (n=23), thermotherapy (n=22), or relaxing room therapy (n=23) for a total of 10 sessions over 12 weeks. Mean reduction in anxiety was measured by the Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HARS). Secondary outcomes included 50% reduction in HARS and symptom resolution of GAD, changes in depressive symptoms (Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-8)), worry and GAD-related disability. We compared changes in these outcomes in the massage and control groups posttreatment and at 6 months using generalized estimating equation (GEE) regression.
All groups had improved by the end of treatment (adjusted mean change scores for the HARS ranged from -10.0 to -13.0; P<.001) and maintained their gains at the 26-week followup. No differences were seen between groups (P=.39). Symptom reduction and resolution of GAD, depressive symptoms, worry and disability showed similar patterns.
Massage was not superior to the control treatments, and all showed some clinically important improvements, likely due to some beneficial but generalized relaxation response. Because the relaxing room treatment is substantially less expensive than the other treatments, a similar treatment packaged in a clinically credible manner might be the most cost effective option for persons with GAD who want to try relaxation-oriented CAM therapies.
尽管按摩是最受欢迎的补充和替代医学(CAM)治疗焦虑症的方法之一,但针对已确诊的焦虑症,其疗效从未经过严格评估。本研究评估了按摩治疗广泛性焦虑症(GAD)患者的效果。
68 名 GAD 患者被随机分为按摩组(n=23)、热疗组(n=22)或放松室治疗组(n=23),共进行 10 次治疗,为期 12 周。采用汉密尔顿焦虑量表(HARS)评估焦虑的平均减轻程度。次要结果包括 HARS 降低 50%和 GAD 症状缓解、抑郁症状(患者健康问卷(PHQ-8))变化、担忧和 GAD 相关残疾的变化。我们使用广义估计方程(GEE)回归比较了治疗后和 6 个月时按摩组和对照组这些结果的变化。
所有组在治疗结束时均有改善(HARS 的调整平均变化分数范围为-10.0 至-13.0;P<.001),并在 26 周随访时保持了改善。组间无差异(P=.39)。症状减轻和 GAD 缓解、抑郁症状、担忧和残疾均显示出相似的模式。
按摩并不优于对照组治疗,所有组均显示出一些具有临床意义的改善,可能是由于某种有益但普遍的放松反应。由于放松室治疗比其他治疗方法便宜得多,因此对于想要尝试以放松为导向的 CAM 疗法的 GAD 患者,采用一种具有临床可信度的类似治疗方法可能是最具成本效益的选择。