Department of Psychology, Swarthmore College, PA 19081, USA.
Cognition. 2010 Jul;116(1):42-55. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2010.03.014. Epub 2010 Apr 14.
Scalar inferences are commonly generated when a speaker uses a weaker expression rather than a stronger alternative, e.g., John ate some of the apples implies that he did not eat them all. This article describes a visual-world study investigating how and when perceivers compute these inferences. Participants followed spoken instructions containing the scalar quantifier some directing them to interact with one of several referential targets (e.g., Click on the girl who has some of the balloons). Participants fixated on the target compatible with the implicated meaning of some and avoided a competitor compatible with the literal meaning prior to a disambiguating noun. Further, convergence on the target was as fast for some as for the non-scalar quantifiers none and all. These findings indicate that the scalar inference is computed immediately and is not delayed relative to the literal interpretation of some. It is argued that previous demonstrations that scalar inferences increase processing time are not necessarily due to delays in generating the inference itself, but rather arise because integrating the interpretation of the inference with relevant information in the context may require additional time. With sufficient contextual support, processing delays disappear.
当说话者使用较弱的表达而不是更强的替代词时,通常会产生数量级推理,例如,“约翰吃了一些苹果”意味着他没有吃完所有的苹果。本文描述了一项视觉世界研究,探讨了感知者如何以及何时计算这些推理。参与者遵循包含数量级量词“一些”的口语指令,指导他们与几个参考目标中的一个进行交互(例如,点击那个拿着一些气球的女孩)。参与者在名词有歧义之前,将目光集中在与“一些”暗示的含义一致的目标上,并避免与字面含义一致的竞争者。此外,“一些”与非数量级量词“无”和“都”一样,对目标的趋同速度一样快。这些发现表明,数量级推理是立即计算的,与“一些”的字面解释相比并不延迟。有人认为,先前表明数量级推理会增加处理时间的研究结果不一定是由于生成推理本身的延迟,而是因为将推理的解释与上下文中的相关信息整合可能需要额外的时间。有了足够的上下文支持,处理延迟就会消失。