Department of Epidemiology and Population Health, School of Public Health and Information Sciences, University of Louisville, Louisville, KY 40202, USA.
Drug Alcohol Rev. 2010 Mar;29(2):121-30. doi: 10.1111/j.1465-3362.2009.00143.x.
It is now widely understood by tobacco research and policy experts that smokeless tobacco (ST) use confers significantly less risk than smoking, but no studies have assessed tobacco risk perceptions in highly educated populations. The purpose of this study was to explore the perception of risks related to smoking and ST use among full-time faculty on two campuses at the University of Louisville.
In October 2007, a survey that quantified risk perceptions of cigarette smoking and ST use with respect to four health domains (general health, heart attack/stroke, all cancer, oral cancer) was sent to 1610 full-time faculty at the Belknap and the Health Sciences Center (HSC) campuses of the University of Louisville, and 597 (37%) returned a completed survey.
Overall, cigarettes were considered as high risk for all health domains by large majorities (75-97%). Except for heart attack/stroke, ST was also considered as high risk by the majority of faculty (69-87%), and at least half perceived cigarettes and ST to be equally harmful across all domains. HSC faculty had somewhat more accurate risk perceptions than Belknap faculty for ST, but both groups overestimated the risks, especially for oral cancer.
This study found that the risks of ST use are overestimated and conflated to that of cigarettes among highly educated professionals, demonstrating the need for better education about the risks of tobacco use and for communication of accurate information by health organisations and agencies.
现在,烟草研究和政策专家广泛认为,使用无烟烟草(ST)的风险明显低于吸烟,但没有研究评估过受过高等教育人群对烟草风险的认知。本研究旨在探讨路易斯维尔大学两个校区的全职教师对吸烟和 ST 使用相关风险的认知。
2007 年 10 月,一项调查向路易斯维尔大学贝尔纳普校区和健康科学中心(HSC)的 1610 名全职教师发送了一份问卷,量化了他们对吸烟和 ST 使用在四个健康领域(一般健康、心脏病/中风、所有癌症、口腔癌)的风险感知,共收回 597 份(37%)完整问卷。
总体而言,绝大多数人(75-97%)认为香烟在所有健康领域都存在高风险。除了心脏病/中风,ST 也被大多数教师认为是高风险(69-87%),至少有一半人认为香烟和 ST 在所有领域都同样有害。HSC 校区的教师对 ST 的风险认知比贝尔纳普校区的教师稍准确,但两组都高估了风险,尤其是对口腔癌的风险。
本研究发现,受过高等教育的专业人员高估了 ST 使用的风险,并将其与香烟的风险混为一谈,这表明需要更好地教育人们关于烟草使用的风险,并需要健康组织和机构传达准确的信息。