Eardley W G P, Taylor D M, Parker P J
Department of Orthopaedics, Friarage Hospital, Northallerton, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2010 Jul;92(5):411-6. doi: 10.1308/003588410X12664192074973. Epub 2010 May 19.
The management of complex extremity injury, which may require assessment of limb viability and performance of amputation, is a challenge to those involved in its emergent and definitive care. Concern exists regarding the exposure of orthopaedic trainees to such cases due both to changes in training and centralisation of trauma services.
This is a web-based observational study by survey, investigating the confidence and perceived adequacy of training of UK orthopaedic specialist trainees in the assessment of limb viability and amputation surgery. 222 responses from 888 trainees were required to achieve a < 5% error rate with 90% confidence; 232 surveys were completed.
Trainee confidence in dealing with the assessment of limb viability is high despite infrequent exposure to cases. The majority of trainees perceive their training in limb viability assessment as adequate. For performance of amputation, exposure is minimal, confidence is lower and 36% of trainees regard their training as inadequate.
Limb viability assessment is an area in which trainees feel confident and well trained. There is, however, a perceived training inadequacy in amputation surgery and a corresponding lack of confidence for many trainees, irrespective of training year. This is the first study to offer an insight into specific training experiences of junior orthopaedic surgeons at a national level and it should drive the development of opportunities for trainees to develop skills in amputation surgery.
复杂肢体损伤的处理可能需要评估肢体的存活能力并进行截肢手术,这对参与其急诊和确定性治疗的人员来说是一项挑战。由于培训的变化和创伤服务的集中化,骨科实习生接触此类病例的机会减少,这引发了人们的担忧。
这是一项基于网络的调查观察性研究,旨在调查英国骨科专科实习生在评估肢体存活能力和截肢手术方面的信心以及他们对培训充分性的认知。需要888名实习生中的222份回复才能在90%的置信度下实现误差率小于5%;共完成了232份调查问卷。
尽管接触此类病例的机会不多,但实习生在处理肢体存活能力评估方面的信心很高。大多数实习生认为他们在肢体存活能力评估方面的培训是充分的。对于截肢手术,实习生的接触机会很少,信心较低,36%的实习生认为他们的培训不足。
肢体存活能力评估是实习生感到有信心且训练有素的领域。然而,无论培训年份如何,许多实习生都认为截肢手术的培训不足,相应地信心也不足。这是第一项在国家层面深入了解初级骨科外科医生特定培训经历的研究,它应该推动为实习生提供发展截肢手术技能机会的相关发展。