Badve Siddharth A, Bhojraj Shekhar Y, Nene Abhay M, Varma Raghuprasad, Mohite Sheetal, Kalkotwar Sameer, Gupta Ankur
Department Of Orthopaedics, T. N. Medical College and B.Y.L. Nair Hospital, Research Fellow, Spine Foundation, Mumbai, India.
Indian J Orthop. 2010 Jul;44(3):270-6. doi: 10.4103/0019-5413.65151.
Unstable spinal lesions in patients with ankylosing spondylitis are common and have a high incidence of associated neurological deficit. The evolution and presentation of these lesions is unclear and the management strategies can be confusing. We present retrospective analysis of the cases of ankylosing spondylitis developing spinal instability either due to spondylodiscitis or fractures for mechanisms of injury, presentations, management strategies and outcome.
In a retrospective analysis of 16 cases of ankylosing spondylitis, treated surgically for unstable spinal lesions over a period of 12 years (1995-2007); 87.5% (n=14) patients had low energy (no obvious/trivial) trauma while 12.5% (n=2) patients sustained high energy trauma. The most common presentation was pain associated with neurological deficit. The surgical indications included neurological deficit, chronic pain due to instability and progressive deformity. All patients were treated surgically with anterior surgery in 18.8% (n=3) patients, posterior in 56.2% (n=9) patients and combined approach in 25% (n=4) patients. Instrumented fusion was carried out in 87.5% (n=14) patients. Average surgical duration was 3.84 (Range 2-7.5) hours, blood loss 765.6 (+/- 472.5) ml and follow-up 54.5 (Range 18-54) months. The patients were evaluated for pain score, Frankel neurological grading, deformity progression and radiological fusion. One patient died of medical complications a week following surgery.
Intra-operative adverse events like dural tears and inadequate deformity correction occurred in 18.7% (n=3) patients (Cases 6, 7 and 8) which could be managed conservatively. There was a significant improvement in the Visual analogue score for pain from a pre-surgical median of 8 to post-surgical median of 2 (P=0.001), while the neurological status improved in 90% (n=9) patients among those with preoperative neurological deficit who could be followed-up (n =10). Frankel grading improved from C to E in 31.25% (n=5) patients, D to E in 12.5% (n=2) and B to D in 12.5% (n=2), while it remained unchanged in the remaining - E in 31.25% (n=5), B in 6.25% (n=1) and D in 6.25% (n=1). Fusion occurred in 11 (68.7%) patients, while 12.5% (n=2) had pseudoarthrosis and 12.5% (n=2) patients had evidence of inadequate fusion. 68.7% (n=11) patients regained their pre-injury functional status, with no spine related complaints and 25% (n=4) patients had complaints like chronic back pain and deformity progression. In one patient (6.2%) who died of medical complications a week following surgery, the neurological function remained unchanged (Frankel grade D). Persistent back pain attributed to inadequate fusion/ pseudoarthrosis could be managed conservatively in 12.5% (n=2) patients. Progression of deformity and pain secondary to pseudoarthrosis, requiring revision surgery was noted in one patient (6.2%). One patient (6.2%) had no neurological recovery following the surgery and continued to have nonfunctional neurological status.
In ankylosing spondylitis, the diagnosis of unstable spinal lesions needs high index of suspicion and extensive radiological evaluation Surgery is indicated if neurological deficit, two/three column injury, significant pain and progressive deformity are present. Long segment instrumentation and fusion is ideal.
强直性脊柱炎患者的脊柱不稳定病变很常见,且伴有神经功能缺损的发生率很高。这些病变的演变和表现尚不清楚,治疗策略也可能令人困惑。我们对因椎间盘炎或骨折导致脊柱不稳定的强直性脊柱炎病例进行回顾性分析,以探讨损伤机制、表现、治疗策略及结果。
回顾性分析16例强直性脊柱炎患者,在12年期间(1995 - 2007年)因脊柱不稳定病变接受手术治疗;87.5%(n = 14)的患者遭受低能量(无明显/轻微)创伤,而12.5%(n = 2)的患者遭受高能量创伤。最常见的表现是伴有神经功能缺损的疼痛。手术指征包括神经功能缺损、因不稳定导致的慢性疼痛和进行性畸形。所有患者均接受手术治疗,18.8%(n = 3)的患者采用前路手术,56.2%(n = 9)的患者采用后路手术,25%(n = 4)的患者采用联合手术。87.5%(n = 14)的患者进行了器械融合。平均手术时间为3.84(范围2 - 7.5)小时,失血量为765.6(±472.5)ml,随访时间为54.5(范围18 - 54)个月。对患者进行疼痛评分、Frankel神经功能分级、畸形进展及影像学融合评估。1例患者术后1周死于医疗并发症。
18.7%(n = 3)的患者(病例6、7和8)发生术中不良事件,如硬脊膜撕裂和畸形矫正不足,可保守处理。疼痛视觉模拟评分从术前中位数8显著改善为术后中位数2(P = 0.001),术前有神经功能缺损且可随访的患者中,90%(n = 9)的患者神经功能得到改善(n = 10)。Frankel分级从C级改善到E级的患者占31.25%(n = 5),从D级改善到E级的患者占12.5%(n = 2),从B级改善到D级的患者占12.5%(n = 2),其余患者分级保持不变——E级占31.25%(n = 5),B级占6.25%(n = 1),D级占6.25%(n = 1)。11例(68.7%)患者实现融合,12.5%(n = 2)的患者发生假关节形成,12.5%(n = 2)的患者有融合不足的证据。68.7%(n = 11)的患者恢复到受伤前的功能状态,无脊柱相关主诉,25%(n = 4)的患者有慢性背痛和畸形进展等主诉。1例术后1周死于医疗并发症的患者(6.2%),其神经功能保持不变(Frankel分级D级)。12.5%(n = 2)的患者因融合不足/假关节形成导致的持续性背痛可保守处理。1例患者(6.2%)因假关节形成导致畸形和疼痛进展,需要翻修手术。1例患者(6.2%)术后神经功能未恢复,仍处于无功能神经状态。
在强直性脊柱炎中,脊柱不稳定病变的诊断需要高度怀疑并进行广泛的影像学评估。如果存在神经功能缺损、两柱/三柱损伤、明显疼痛和进行性畸形,则应进行手术。长节段器械固定融合是理想的治疗方法。