The Phoenix Road Safety Studies, Department of Management, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan 52900, Israel.
Accid Anal Prev. 2010 Nov;42(6):2125-31. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2010.07.002. Epub 2010 Aug 3.
The current study set to examine whether there are inter-generational and gender-based differences between family members self-assessing their ability to drive under normal conditions and while under the influence of either alcohol or drugs. Participants were 135 young-adults and both their parents, consisting 45 family triads, who received self-assessment questionnaires relating to their driving skills in various road scenarios. Each family triad was randomly assigned to one of three groups: either requested to base the assessments on normal driving conditions, or under the influence of either drugs or alcohol, thus forming a control group, and two experimental groups (alcohol and drugs), respectively. The findings indicate the assessments of both the alcohol and drugs groups were more severe than those of the control group. The alcohol group assessments were less strict than the drug group assessment (non-significantly). Inter-generational differences indicated that the parents' driving-skills assessments were lower than those of their offspring, corresponding with previous findings (Elkind, 1967; Finn and Bragg, 1986). A significant within-subject interaction has been found between the respondent's gender and familial relations regarding the self-assessment of driving skills: male respondents assessed better driving skills compared to the self estimates of both parents (which did not significantly differ). In contrast, female respondents' estimates did not differ from their fathers' and both fathers' and daughters' estimates were significantly higher than that of the mothers in each family.
本研究旨在考察在正常情况下和在酒精或药物影响下,家庭成员自我评估驾驶能力是否存在代际和性别差异。参与者包括 135 名年轻成年人及其父母,共有 45 个家庭三人组,他们收到了与各种道路场景下驾驶技能相关的自我评估问卷。每个家庭三人组被随机分配到三个组之一:要求基于正常驾驶条件进行评估,或在酒精或药物的影响下进行评估,从而形成对照组和两个实验组(酒精组和药物组)。研究结果表明,酒精组和药物组的评估结果比对照组更严格。酒精组的评估结果比药物组的评估结果略宽松(无显著差异)。代际差异表明,父母的驾驶技能评估低于子女的评估,这与之前的研究结果一致(Elkind,1967;Finn 和 Bragg,1986)。在自我评估驾驶技能方面,被试的性别和家庭关系之间存在显著的主体内交互作用:男性被试的评估结果优于父母的自我评估结果(无显著差异)。相比之下,女性被试的评估结果与其父亲的评估结果没有差异,而父亲和女儿的评估结果在每个家庭中均显著高于母亲的评估结果。