Santos E M, Paula J F R, Motta P M C, Heinemann M B, Leite R C, Haddad J P A, Del Puerto H L, Reis J K P
Departamento de Medicina Veterinária Preventiva, Escola de Veterinária, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brasil.
Genet Mol Res. 2010 Aug 17;9(3):1591-8. doi: 10.4238/vol9-3gmr818.
We compared three different protocols for DNA extraction from horse peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and lung fragments, determining average final DNA concentration, purity, percentage of PCR amplification using beta-actin, and cost. Thirty-four samples from PBMC, and 33 samples from lung fragments were submitted to DNA extraction by three different protocols. Protocol A consisted of a phenol-chloroform and isoamylic alcohol extraction, Protocol B used alkaline extraction with NaOH, and Protocol C used the DNAzol((R)) reagent kit. Protocol A was the best option for DNA extraction from lung fragments, producing high DNA concentrations, with high sensitivity in PCR amplification (100%), followed by Protocols C and B. On the other hand, for PBMC samples, Protocol B gave the highest sensitivity in PCR amplification (100%), followed by Protocols C and A. We conclude that Protocol A should be used for PCR diagnosis from lung fragment samples, while Protocol B should be used for PBMC.
我们比较了三种从马外周血单核细胞(PBMC)和肺组织碎片中提取DNA的不同方法,测定了最终DNA的平均浓度、纯度、使用β-肌动蛋白进行PCR扩增的百分比以及成本。对34份PBMC样本和33份肺组织碎片样本采用三种不同方法进行DNA提取。方法A采用苯酚-氯仿和异戊醇提取法,方法B使用NaOH进行碱提取,方法C使用DNAzol®试剂试剂盒。方法A是从肺组织碎片中提取DNA的最佳选择,可产生高浓度DNA,PCR扩增灵敏度高(100%),其次是方法C和方法B。另一方面,对于PBMC样本,方法B在PCR扩增中灵敏度最高(100%),其次是方法C和方法A。我们得出结论,方法A应用于从肺组织碎片样本进行PCR诊断,而方法B应用于PBMC样本。