Yeow C H, Lee P V S, Goh J C H
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, National University of Singapore, Singapore.
Knee. 2011 Dec;18(6):407-11. doi: 10.1016/j.knee.2010.07.011. Epub 2010 Aug 24.
Athletic shoes can directly provide shock absorption at the foot due to its cushioning properties, however it remains unclear how these shoes may affect the level of energy dissipation contributed by the knee joint. This study sought to investigate biomechanical differences, in terms of knee kinematics, kinetics and energetics, between barefoot and shod landing from different heights. Twelve healthy male recreational athletes were recruited and instructed to perform double-leg landing from 0.3-m and 0.6-m heights in barefoot and shod conditions. The shoe model tested was Brooks Maximus II. Markers were placed on the subjects based on the Plug-in Gait Marker Set. Force-plates and motion-capture system were used to capture ground reaction force (GRF) and kinematics data respectively. 2×2-ANOVA (barefoot/shod condition×landing height) was performed to examine differences in knee kinematics, kinetics and energetics between barefoot and shod conditions from different landing heights. Peak GRF was not significantly different (p=0.732-0.824) between barefoot and shod conditions for both landing heights. Knee range-of-motion, flexion angular velocity, external knee flexion moment, and joint power and work were higher during shod landing (p<0.001 to p=0.007), compared to barefoot landing for both landing heights. No significant interactions (p=0.073-0.933) were found between landing height and barefoot/shod condition for the tested parameters. While the increase in landing height can elevate knee energetics independent of barefoot/shod conditions, we have also shown that the shod condition was able to augment the level of energy dissipation contributed by the knee joint, via the knee extensors, regardless of the tested landing heights.
运动鞋因其缓冲特性可直接在足部提供减震作用,然而这些鞋子如何影响膝关节的能量耗散水平仍不清楚。本研究旨在调查在不同高度下,赤脚和穿鞋着地时膝关节在运动学、动力学和能量学方面的生物力学差异。招募了12名健康的男性休闲运动员,并指示他们在赤脚和穿鞋条件下从0.3米和0.6米的高度进行双腿着地。测试的鞋款型号为布鲁克斯Maximus II。根据插件式步态标记集在受试者身上放置标记。分别使用测力台和动作捕捉系统来采集地面反作用力(GRF)和运动学数据。进行2×2方差分析(赤脚/穿鞋条件×着地高度),以检查不同着地高度下赤脚和穿鞋条件之间膝关节运动学、动力学和能量学的差异。两种着地高度下,赤脚和穿鞋条件之间的峰值GRF均无显著差异(p = 0.732 - 0.824)。与两种着地高度下的赤脚着地相比,穿鞋着地时膝关节的活动范围、屈曲角速度、膝关节外侧屈曲力矩以及关节功率和功更高(p < 0.001至p = 0.007)。对于测试参数,着地高度与赤脚/穿鞋条件之间未发现显著交互作用(p = 0.073 - 0.933)。虽然着地高度的增加可独立于赤脚/穿鞋条件提高膝关节能量学,但我们还表明,无论测试的着地高度如何,穿鞋条件都能够通过膝关节伸肌增强膝关节贡献的能量耗散水平。