International Centre for Allied Health Evidence, University of South Australia, Adelaide;
Int J Gen Med. 2010 Aug 30;3:231-7. doi: 10.2147/ijgm.s12603.
Personal alarms are proposed as a reliable mechanism for older people to obtain assistance after falling. However, little is known about how older people feel about owning and using personal alarms.
This paper reports on experiences of independently living older people, who have recently fallen, regarding alarm use and their independence.
Volunteers older than 65 years who had sustained a fall in the previous six months were sought via community invitations. Semistructured telephone interviews were conducted to gain information about their fall and their perspectives on personal alarm use. Interviews were content-analyzed to identify key concepts and themes.
Thirty-one interviews were conducted. Twenty callers owned personal alarms. Four subgroups of older fallers were identified; the first group used personal alarms effectively and were advocates for their benefits, the second group owned an alarm but did not use it effectively, the third group did not own alarms mostly because of cost, although were receptive to an alarm should one be provided, and the fourth group did not have an alarm and would not use it even if it was provided.
Personal alarms produce positive experiences when used effectively by the right people. The cost of personal alarms prohibits some older fallers from being effective alarm users. However, other elderly fallers remain unwilling to consider alarm use even if one was provided. In view of their cost, personal alarms should be targeted to people who will benefit most. Alternative strategies should be considered when alarms are unlikely to be used appropriately.
个人警报器被提议为老年人在摔倒后获得帮助的可靠机制。然而,对于老年人对拥有和使用个人警报器的看法,人们知之甚少。
本文报告了最近摔倒的独立生活的老年人对报警使用和独立性的体验。
通过社区邀请,寻找年龄在 65 岁以上、在过去六个月内摔倒过的志愿者。通过半结构化电话访谈,了解他们的摔倒情况和对个人警报器使用的看法。对访谈进行内容分析,以确定关键概念和主题。
共进行了 31 次访谈。20 名呼叫者拥有个人警报器。确定了 4 组不同的老年跌倒者:第一组有效地使用个人警报器,并支持其益处;第二组拥有警报器但未有效使用;第三组主要因费用而未拥有警报器,但对提供的警报器持开放态度;第四组没有警报器,即使提供了也不会使用。
当个人警报器被正确使用的人有效地使用时,会产生积极的体验。个人警报器的成本阻止了一些老年跌倒者成为有效的警报器使用者。然而,其他老年跌倒者仍然不愿意考虑使用警报器,即使提供了。鉴于其成本,个人警报器应针对最能受益的人群。当警报器不太可能被正确使用时,应考虑替代策略。