Department of Bioethics, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Reprod Biomed Online. 2010 Dec;21(7):838-47. doi: 10.1016/j.rbmo.2010.09.009. Epub 2010 Sep 26.
This article reports the results from a study of couples participating in a research protocol in which IVF/preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) was available for non-medical sex selection. The study sought to characterize the moral attitudes and beliefs of couples actively pursuing IVF/PGD solely for purposes related to sex selection. Eighteen couples participated in ethnographic interviews from November 2005 to April 2006. These interviews explored couples' motivations for pursuing sex selection, moral beliefs and attitudes regarding sex selection and sources of moral ambivalence about the use of IVF/PGD for sex selection. Couples reported a combination of motivations for pursuing sex selection, including a desire to limit family size, concerns about parental age and financial concerns about multiple pregnancies. Many couples compared their decision to choices about abortion, maintaining that individuals have a right to make such decisions privately. Couples frequently expressed anxiety about telling their other children and family members about their plans to use IVF/PGD for sex selection. Few couples cited concerns about the physical or emotional burdens of IVF/PGD. The study's findings suggest that couples pursuing IVF/PGD for sex selection view this as an ethically complex decision and express considerable uncertainty about the ethical acceptability of this practice.
这篇文章报告了一项针对参与研究方案的夫妇的研究结果,该方案中提供了体外受精/胚胎植入前遗传学诊断(PGD),用于非医学性别选择。该研究旨在描述积极追求仅与性别选择相关的 IVF/PGD 的夫妇的道德态度和信念。18 对夫妇于 2005 年 11 月至 2006 年 4 月参加了人种学访谈。这些访谈探讨了夫妇追求性别选择的动机、对性别选择的道德信念和态度,以及对使用 IVF/PGD 进行性别选择的道德矛盾的来源。夫妇报告了追求性别选择的多种动机,包括限制家庭规模的愿望、对父母年龄的担忧以及对多胎妊娠的经济担忧。许多夫妇将他们的决定与堕胎选择进行了比较,认为个人有权私下做出这样的决定。夫妇经常对向其他孩子和家庭成员透露他们计划使用 IVF/PGD 进行性别选择表示焦虑。很少有夫妇提到对 IVF/PGD 的身体或情感负担的担忧。该研究的结果表明,追求 IVF/PGD 进行性别选择的夫妇认为这是一个道德上复杂的决定,并对这种做法的道德可接受性表示相当大的不确定性。