Sheba Medical Center, Ramat Gan, Israel.
J Alzheimers Dis. 2011;23(4):709-16. doi: 10.3233/JAD-2010-101327.
Holocaust and Nazi concentration camp survivors were subjects to prolonged and multi-dimensional trauma and stress. The aim of the present study was to assess the association between exposure to such trauma during late adolescence and adulthood with dementia at old age. In 1963, approximately 10,000 male civil servants aged 40-71 participated in the Israel Ischemic Heart Disease (IIHD) study. Of them, 691 reported having survived Nazi concentration camps [concentration Camp Survivors (CCS)]. Additional 2316 participants were holocaust survivors but not concentration camp survivors (HSNCC) and 1688 were born in European countries but not exposed to the Holocaust (NH). Dementia was assessed in 1999-2000, over three decades later, in 1889 survivors of the original IIHD cohort; 139 of whom were CCS, 435 were HSNCC, and 236 were NH. Dementia prevalence was 11.5% in CCS, 12.6% in HSNCC, and 15.7% in NH. The odds ratio of dementia prevalence, estimated by age adjusted logistic regression, for CCS as compared to HSNCC was 0.97 (95% CI: 0.53-1.77), approximate Z = -0.10; p = 0.92. Further adjustment for socioeconomic status, diabetes mellitus, and other co-morbidity at midlife (coronary heart disease, lung, and kidney disease), and height did not change the results substantially. Thus, in subjects who survived until old age, late adolescence and adulthood exposure to extreme stress, as reflected by experiencing holocaust and Nazi concentration camps, was not associated with increased prevalence of dementia. Individuals who survived concentration camps and then lived into old age may carry survival advantages that are associated with protection from dementia and mortality.
大屠杀和纳粹集中营幸存者经历了长期的多维创伤和压力。本研究的目的是评估青少年晚期和成年期暴露于此类创伤与老年痴呆症的关系。1963 年,约 10000 名年龄在 40-71 岁的男性公务员参加了以色列缺血性心脏病(IIHD)研究。其中,691 人报告曾在纳粹集中营中幸存[集中营幸存者(CCS)]。另外 2316 名参与者是大屠杀幸存者但不是集中营幸存者(HSNCC),1688 人出生在欧洲国家但没有经历过大屠杀(NH)。痴呆症于 30 多年后在 1999-2000 年进行评估,在最初 IIHD 队列的 1889 名幸存者中进行评估;其中 139 人是 CCS,435 人是 HSNCC,236 人是 NH。CCS 的痴呆症患病率为 11.5%,HSNCC 为 12.6%,NH 为 15.7%。CCS 与 HSNCC 相比,年龄调整后的 logistic 回归估计的痴呆症患病率的优势比为 0.97(95%CI:0.53-1.77),近似 Z = -0.10;p = 0.92。进一步调整中年时的社会经济地位、糖尿病和其他合并症(冠心病、肺部和肾脏疾病)以及身高并没有显著改变结果。因此,在幸存至老年的受试者中,青少年晚期和成年期暴露于极端压力,如经历大屠杀和纳粹集中营,与痴呆症患病率的增加无关。那些经历过集中营并存活到老年的人可能具有生存优势,这些优势与预防痴呆症和死亡有关。