Can Fam Physician. 1990 Aug;36:1402-6.
Ontario Health service organizations (HSOs) provide physician services funded by monthly payments per enrollee and one-third the cost of hospital days saved. They reduce hospitalization rates, but are providing less multidisciplinary care than expected. American health maintenance organizations (HMOs) provide both physicians' services and hospital care. They reduce hospitalizations, and their physicians manage greater patient loads, while patients receive equivalent ambulatory care. Comprehensive health organizations (CHOs) in Ontario provide almost all health services for their current per capita cost. Greater cost-effectiveness is expected through greater use of management, deinstitutionalization, auxiliary personnel, and health promotion. Proponents of organized medicine have strong reservations about the expected results. The ethics of providing incentives (i.e., capitation) to underservice patients should also be considered.
安大略省的卫生服务组织(HSO)按照每位参保人的月缴费额以及节省的三分之一住院天数来支付医生薪酬。这些组织降低了住院率,但提供的多学科护理比预期的要少。美国的健康维护组织(HMO)既提供医生服务,也提供医院护理。它们降低了住院率,医生管理的患者量更大,而患者则接受同等的门诊护理。安大略省的综合性卫生组织(CHO)为其当前的人均成本提供几乎所有的卫生服务。通过更多地利用管理、去机构化、辅助人员和促进健康,可以实现更高的成本效益。有组织的医学的支持者对预期结果持强烈保留意见。为服务不足的患者提供激励(即人头费)的道德问题也应该考虑。