Department of Ophthalmology, Leicester Royal Infirmary, Leicester, UK.
Eye (Lond). 2011 Mar;25(3):365-9. doi: 10.1038/eye.2010.210. Epub 2011 Jan 21.
There is lack of consensus among Primary Health Care Trusts (PCTs) and health insurers on how to reimburse ptosis surgery and upper lid blepharoplasty, as these procedures can be regarded as cosmetic. Standardised photographs are expensive and difficult to achieve, whilst the routine 24-2 visual field lacks the range to detect visually significant superior field defects.AimTo introduce a modified visual field designed to assess the functional disability associated with ptosis and dermatochalasis and to demonstrate the effectiveness of surgery in improving the visual field.
Patients who had surgery for ptosis or dermatochalasis between January 2006 and December 2009 were prospectively invited to perform a modified visual field test pre- and post-operatively.
In total, 97 patients amounting to 194 eyes were included in the study. Ninety five eyes had aponeurotic repair with or without blepharoplasty and 77 eyes had blepharoplasty alone. This modified test has a sensitivity of 98.8% of detecting ptosis. For patients who underwent ptosis surgery with or without blepharoplasty, 84.2% recorded an improvement in points seen with the test and 81% recorded an improvement in visual field height. For those who had blepharoplasty alone, 90.9% recorded an improvement in points seen in the modified visual field test and 80.6% had improvement in visual field height.
Our modified visual field assessment is a quick and easy way to assess patient disability associated with ptosis and dermatochalasis. Surgery improves the demonstrated defect, confirming that ptosis and dermatochalasis can be considered a functional rather than cosmetic issue.
初级保健信托基金(PCTs)和健康保险公司在如何为上睑下垂手术和上睑成形术报销费用方面缺乏共识,因为这些手术可以被视为美容手术。标准化的照片既昂贵又难以获得,而常规的 24-2 视野范围不足以检测到明显的上视野缺陷。目的:介绍一种改良的视野检查方法,用于评估上睑下垂和皮肤松弛引起的功能障碍,并证明手术在改善视野方面的有效性。
2006 年 1 月至 2009 年 12 月期间,前瞻性邀请因上睑下垂或皮肤松弛而行手术的患者在术前和术后进行改良视野检查。
共有 97 例患者(194 只眼)纳入研究。95 只眼行腱膜修复术,伴或不伴眼睑成形术,77 只眼单独行眼睑成形术。该改良测试检测上睑下垂的敏感度为 98.8%。对于行上睑下垂手术(伴或不伴眼睑成形术)的患者,84.2%的患者记录到测试中所见的点数有所改善,81%的患者记录到视野高度有所改善。对于仅行眼睑成形术的患者,90.9%的患者记录到改良视野测试中所见的点数有所改善,80.6%的患者记录到视野高度有所改善。
我们的改良视野评估是一种快速、简便的方法,可评估与上睑下垂和皮肤松弛相关的患者残疾程度。手术改善了所显示的缺陷,证实了上睑下垂和皮肤松弛可以被认为是一种功能问题,而不是美容问题。