S. CHAKRABARTI, MD., MRCPsych., Assistant Professor, Department of Psychiatry, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh-160012.
Indian J Psychiatry. 2000 Jan;42(1):21-8.
Although depression is an eminently treatable condition, inadequate pharmacotherapy is far too common. Lack of uniform standards of care across different settings characterises psychiatric practice in a developing country like India. But, there have hardly been any attempts at assessing the standards of care being delivered. A case note study was carried out of patients attending a general hospital psychiatric unit with depression, over a one year period, to evaluate the nature and adequacy of antidepressant therapy. Prescribing patterns in 108 cases fulfilling the selection criteria, were examined. The sample consisted mainly of young to middle aged patients, predominantly female, with moderately severe depressive episodes. Antidepressants were prescribed universally with TCAs (mainly Imipraminc), followed by Fluoxetine being the most common drugs used. Pharmacotherapy was often found to be deficient in several areas such as, starting doses, rate of increase in dose, maximum doses used, dose titrations, duration of treatment, change of drugs, recording of side effects and compliance etc. Results regarding norms for adequate doses and periods of treatment before switching drugs, for the kind of patients included in this study, were unclear, and need to be explored further. Inadequate treatment can have a number of adverse consequences, hence some guidelines for minimum standards of care while undertaking antidepressant treatment need to be formulated for India and other developing countries, as none exist at present.
尽管抑郁症是一种完全可以治疗的疾病,但药物治疗不足的情况却非常普遍。在印度这样的发展中国家,不同环境下的精神科医疗实践缺乏统一的护理标准。但是,几乎没有任何尝试来评估所提供的护理标准。我们对在一家综合医院精神科病房就诊的抑郁症患者进行了病例记录研究,以评估抗抑郁治疗的性质和充分性。在一年的时间里,对符合选择标准的 108 例患者进行了处方模式检查。该样本主要由年轻到中年的患者组成,女性居多,抑郁发作程度中等严重。普遍使用 TCAs(主要是丙咪嗪)开出处方,其次是氟西汀,这两种药物是最常用的药物。药物治疗在多个方面经常被发现不足,例如起始剂量、剂量增加速度、最大剂量使用、剂量滴定、治疗持续时间、药物更换、记录副作用和依从性等。关于在更换药物之前达到足够剂量和治疗期的标准,对于包括在本研究中的这类患者,结果并不明确,需要进一步探索。不充分的治疗可能会带来许多不良后果,因此需要为印度和其他发展中国家制定最低的护理标准指南,因为目前还没有此类指南。