Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC.
Can J Public Health. 2011 Jan-Feb;102(1):47-50. doi: 10.1007/BF03404876.
Control measures of mumps involve isolation of those symptomatic or potentially exposed. Recent guidelines have recommended shortening the isolation period from 9 days to 5 days after the onset of parotitis, despite using mainly historical evidence. In British Columbia, mumps circulated in a predominantly unvaccinated population in 2008. We compared laboratory findings between the different vaccination groups and assessed the period of mumps viral detection after onset of parotitis.
Demographic and clinical data were collected according to guidelines during the course of the outbreak. Clinical specimens, including buccal swabs, urine, CSF and sera, were collected on a single visit upon presentation for diagnosis. Laboratory diagnosis of mumps was confirmed by either virus detection by PCR and/or isolation in cell culture from clinical specimens, or by serology.
Laboratory testing confirmed mumps on 85 (74%) of 115 cases by virus detection and/or serology. Thirty-nine (78%) of 50 cases had virus detected within the first 5 days after onset of parotitis, with the rate highest in specimens collected early. However, virus could be detected in 5 (56%) of 9 cases after day 5 and up to day 9.
Our study questions whether a 5-day isolation period is sufficient to prevent mumps transmission in a susceptible population. Our observations are based on single specimen submission, whereas an optimal study design would entail serial collection after presentation of parotitis, as this reflects true viral shedding. Further investigations are warranted to validate patient isolation guidelines.
腮腺炎的控制措施包括隔离有症状或有潜在暴露风险的患者。尽管主要依据历史证据,最近的指南建议将腮腺炎发病后隔离期从 9 天缩短至 5 天。2008 年,不列颠哥伦比亚省的腮腺炎在未接种疫苗的人群中广泛传播。我们比较了不同疫苗接种组的实验室发现,并评估了腮腺炎发病后腮腺炎病毒检测的持续时间。
根据疫情期间的指南收集人口统计学和临床数据。在就诊时进行单次就诊,收集临床标本,包括口腔拭子、尿液、CSF 和血清,用于诊断。通过从临床标本中通过 PCR 检测病毒和/或细胞培养分离,或通过血清学检测来确认腮腺炎的实验室诊断。
实验室检测通过病毒检测和/或血清学确认了 115 例病例中的 85 例(74%)。50 例中有 39 例(78%)在腮腺炎发病后 5 天内检测到病毒,最早采集的标本中病毒检出率最高。然而,在发病后第 5 天至第 9 天,仍可检测到 5 例(56%)病例中的病毒。
我们的研究对在易感人群中,5 天的隔离期是否足以预防腮腺炎传播提出了质疑。我们的观察结果基于单次标本提交,而最佳研究设计需要在腮腺炎发病后进行连续采集,因为这反映了真实的病毒脱落情况。需要进一步调查来验证患者隔离指南。