Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Med Educ. 2011 May;45(5):471-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2010.03883.x.
Interprofessional education (IPE) has been gaining traction in post-secondary institutions. Many schools introduce IPE early to their health professional students, often in the context of a large-scale event in Year 1. This paper presents findings from a study undertaken by a medical student (a classmate of the research participants) and details Year 1 students' initial perceptions of IPE.
Using an exploratory case study approach, eight focus groups of medical, pharmacy, dental, occupational therapy and social work students were gathered over 2 years (2007 and 2008). All participants had attended an IPE event delivered to nearly 1200 students each year. All data were analysed using an inductive thematic approach.
The data indicated that, although students were generally positive towards IPE, many expressed dissatisfaction with the way their initial IPE event had been implemented. In particular, students felt that delivering IPE as a large-scale activity limited the amount of meaningful interprofessional interaction that could be achieved. A number of students also expressed concern about the 'artificial' nature of some of their interprofessional activities, which again limited their value. Students went on to offer various suggestions to improve their first exposure to IPE.
Our findings reinforce the notion that students value IPE, but offer some new insights into how introductory IPE programming might be organised. Although large-scale activities can provide IPE activities to a wide range of students, which is advantageous from a specifically administrative perspective, students' opinions reveal that this form of IPE involves a number of challenges in their initial engagement with concepts of interprofessional teamwork and collaboration.
跨专业教育(IPE)在高等教育机构中越来越受到重视。许多学校在学生的第一年就向他们的健康专业学生引入 IPE,通常是在大型活动的背景下。本文介绍了一项由医学生(研究参与者的同学)进行的研究的结果,并详细介绍了一年级学生对 IPE 的初步看法。
使用探索性案例研究方法,在两年(2007 年和 2008 年)期间收集了八组医学、药学、牙科、职业治疗和社会工作专业学生的焦点小组。所有参与者都参加了每年向近 1200 名学生提供的 IPE 活动。所有数据均采用归纳主题分析方法进行分析。
数据表明,尽管学生普遍对 IPE 持积极态度,但许多人对他们最初的 IPE 活动的实施方式表示不满。特别是,学生们认为将 IPE 作为一项大型活动来开展,限制了可以实现的有意义的跨专业互动的数量。一些学生还对一些跨专业活动的“人为”性质表示担忧,这再次限制了其价值。学生们接着提出了一些改进他们第一次接触 IPE 的建议。
我们的研究结果证实了学生重视 IPE 的观点,但也提供了一些关于如何组织介绍性 IPE 计划的新见解。虽然大规模活动可以为广泛的学生提供 IPE 活动,从特定的管理角度来看是有利的,但学生的意见表明,这种形式的 IPE 在他们最初接触跨专业团队合作和协作的概念时存在一些挑战。