Université de Toulouse, Université Paul Sabatier, Centre de Recherche Cerveau et Cognition, 31062 Toulouse, France.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011 May 3;108(18):7635-40. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1016213108. Epub 2011 Apr 18.
Conceptual abilities in animals have been shown at several levels of abstraction, but it is unclear whether the analogy with humans results from convergent evolution or from shared brain mechanisms inherited from a common origin. Macaque monkeys can access "non-similarity-based concepts," such as when sorting pictures containing a superordinate target category (animal, tree, etc.) among other scenes. However, such performances could result from low-level visual processing based on learned regularities of the photographs, such as for scene categorization by artificial systems. By using pictures of man-made objects or animals embedded in man-made or natural contexts, the present study clearly establishes that macaque monkeys based their categorical decision on the presence of the animal targets regardless of the scene backgrounds. However, as is found with humans, monkeys performed better with categorically congruent object/context associations, especially when small object sizes favored background information. The accuracy improvements and the response-speed gains attributable to superordinate category congruency in monkeys were strikingly similar to those of human subjects tested with the same task and stimuli. These results suggest analogous processing of visual information during the activation of abstract representations in both humans and monkeys; they imply a large overlap between superordinate visual representations in humans and macaques as well as the implicit use of experienced associations between object and context.
动物的概念能力已经在多个抽象层次上得到了证明,但尚不清楚这种与人类的类比是来自趋同进化,还是来自共同起源的共享大脑机制。猕猴可以获得“非基于相似性的概念”,例如在其他场景中对包含上位目标类别的图片(动物、树等)进行分类。然而,这样的表现可能源于基于照片的学习规律的低级视觉处理,例如人工系统进行场景分类。通过使用嵌入在人造或自然背景中的人造物体或动物的图片,本研究清楚地表明,猕猴的分类决策是基于动物目标的存在,而不考虑场景背景。然而,与人类一样,猴子在分类上一致的物体/背景关联上表现更好,尤其是当物体尺寸较小时,更有利于背景信息。猴子的分类一致性引起的准确性提高和反应速度提高与用相同任务和刺激测试的人类受试者非常相似。这些结果表明,在人类和猴子的抽象表示的激活过程中,视觉信息的处理是类似的;这意味着人类和猕猴的上位视觉表示之间存在很大的重叠,以及对物体和上下文之间经验关联的隐含使用。