Crosnoe Robert
University of Texas at Austin.
Am Sociol Rev. 2009 Oct 1;74(5):709-730. doi: 10.1177/000312240907400502.
Increasing constraints placed on race-based school diversification have shifted attention to socioeconomic desegregation. Although past research suggests that socioeconomic desegregation can produce heightened achievement, the "frog pond" perspective points to potential problems with socioeconomic desegregation in nonachievement domains. Such problems are important in their own right, and they may also chip away at the magnitude of potential achievement benefits. In this article, I report conducted propensity score analyses and robustness calculations on a sample of public high schools in the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health. As the proportion of the student body with middle- or high-income parents increased, low-income students progressed less far in math and science. Moreover, as the proportion of the student body with middle- or high-income or college-educated parents increased, low-income students experienced more psychosocial problems. Such patterns were often more pronounced among African American and Latino students. These findings suggest curricular and social psychological mechanisms of oft-noted frog pond effects in schools and extend the frog pond framework beyond achievement itself to demographic statuses (e.g., race/ethnicity and SES) perceptually linked to achievement. In terms of policy, these findings indicate that socioeconomic desegregation plans should also attend to equity in course enrollments and the social integration of students more generally.
对基于种族的学校多元化施加的限制日益增加,这使得人们将注意力转向了社会经济层面的种族融合。尽管过去的研究表明,社会经济层面的种族融合能够提高学业成绩,但“青蛙池塘”理论指出,社会经济层面的种族融合在非学业领域可能存在潜在问题。这些问题本身就很重要,而且它们可能还会削弱潜在的学业成绩提升幅度。在本文中,我对青少年健康全国纵向研究中的公立高中样本进行了倾向得分分析和稳健性计算。随着学生群体中父母为中高收入的比例增加,低收入学生在数学和科学方面的进步较小。此外,随着学生群体中父母为中高收入或受过大学教育的比例增加,低收入学生经历了更多的心理社会问题。这种模式在非裔美国学生和拉丁裔学生中往往更为明显。这些发现揭示了学校中常被提及的“青蛙池塘”效应的课程和社会心理机制,并将“青蛙池塘”框架从学业成绩本身扩展到了在认知上与学业成绩相关的人口统计学特征(如种族/族裔和社会经济地位)。在政策方面,这些发现表明,社会经济层面的种族融合计划还应更普遍地关注课程注册的公平性以及学生的社会融合。