Institute of Epidemiology II, Helmholtz Zentrum München, German Research Centre for Environmental Health, Ingolstädter Landstr. 1, 85764 Neuherberg, Germany.
BMC Public Health. 2011 Aug 4;11:620. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-11-620.
Constant high-level numbers of railway suicides indicate that prevention strategies against railway suicides are urgently needed. The main question of the present study was whether pre-crash railway suicide behaviour can be identified, using German Federal Police officers experience with suicidal events in railway related environments.
To collect information on pre-crash railway suicide behaviour, a questionnaire was used and made available on the German Federal Police intranet. A total of 202 subjects (mean age: 41 years, sex: 84.9% male) were included in the analysis. Multivariate logistic regression analyses were performed to predict the prevention of suicide (first model) or demand for counselling (second model) as outcomes. Sex, age, years of service, number of experienced suicides, suicides personally observed, information on suicides obtained from witnesses and finally either counselling/debriefing (first model) or whether officers had prevented a suicide (second model) were used as predictors.
A considerable proportion of police officers reported behavioural patterns preceding a suicide. Half of them observed the dropping or leaving behind of personal belongings or the avoidance of eye contact, more than a third erratic gesture, mimic or movement. Erratic communication patterns and general confusion were each reported by about one quarter. One fifth indicated the influence of alcohol. Less frequently observed behaviour was aimlessly wandering (14.3%) and out of the ordinary clothing (4%). About one third of all railway suicide victims committed suicide in stations. Of those, 70% had chosen an eminent spot. The multivariate logistic regression model using prevented suicides as the outcome identified the number of suicides experienced, counselling/debriefing and having personally observed a suicide as variables with significant impact. The model using counselling/debriefing as the outcome identified age and having prevented a suicide as variables with a significant association.
Our results provide evidence that railway suicides are preceded by identifiable behavioural patterns. This emphasizes the importance of educational efforts, taking into account the knowledge and skills of experienced police officers.
不断出现的铁路自杀高数字表明急需预防铁路自杀的策略。本研究的主要问题是,是否可以利用德国联邦警察在铁路相关环境中处理自杀事件的经验,来识别出撞车前的铁路自杀行为。
为了收集关于撞车前铁路自杀行为的信息,使用了一份问卷,并在德国联邦警察内部网上提供。共有 202 名被试(平均年龄:41 岁,性别:84.9%为男性)被纳入分析。进行了多变量逻辑回归分析,以预测预防自杀(第一模型)或需求咨询(第二模型)作为结果。性别、年龄、服务年限、经历的自杀事件数量、亲自观察到的自杀事件、从目击者处获得的自杀信息以及最终的咨询/疏导(第一模型)或警察是否预防了自杀(第二模型)被用作预测因素。
相当一部分警察报告了自杀前的行为模式。他们中有一半人观察到个人物品的掉落或遗留、避免眼神接触,超过三分之一的人表现出不稳定的姿势、模仿或动作。大约四分之一的人报告了不稳定的沟通模式和普遍的困惑。五分之一的人表示受到了酒精的影响。较少观察到的行为是漫无目的地游荡(14.3%)和不寻常的着装(4%)。大约三分之一的铁路自杀受害者在车站自杀。其中,70%的人选择了一个显眼的地点。使用预防自杀作为结果的多变量逻辑回归模型确定了经历的自杀事件数量、咨询/疏导以及亲自观察到自杀作为具有显著影响的变量。使用咨询/疏导作为结果的模型确定了年龄和预防自杀作为具有显著关联的变量。
我们的结果提供了证据,表明铁路自杀事件之前存在可识别的行为模式。这强调了教育工作的重要性,要考虑到有经验的警察的知识和技能。