Department of Biomedical Engineering, Tampere University of Technology, Tampere, Finland.
Brain Topogr. 2012 Jan;25(1):1-19. doi: 10.1007/s10548-011-0202-1. Epub 2011 Sep 13.
Since the detection of the first biomagnetic signals in 1963 there has been continuous discussion on the properties and relative merits of bioelectric and biomagnetic measurements. In this review article it is briefly discussed the early history of this controversy. Then the theory of the independence and interdependence of bioelectric and biomagnetic signals is explained, and a clinical study on ECG and MCG that strongly supports this theory is presented. The spatial resolutions of EEG and MEG are compared in detail, and the issue of the maximum number of electrodes in EEG is also discussed. Finally, some special properties of EEG and MEG methods are described. In brief, the conclusion is that EEG and MEG are only partially independent and their spatial resolutions are about the same. Recording both of them brings some additional information on the bioelectric activity of the brain. These two methods have certain unique properties that make either of them more beneficial in certain applications.
自 1963 年首次检测到生物磁信号以来,关于生物电和生物磁测量的特性和相对优势一直存在持续的讨论。在这篇综述文章中,简要讨论了这一争议的早期历史。然后解释了生物电和生物磁信号的独立性和相互依赖性理论,并提出了一项强烈支持该理论的关于心电图和磁图的临床研究。详细比较了 EEG 和 MEG 的空间分辨率,并讨论了 EEG 中电极数量的最大问题。最后,描述了 EEG 和 MEG 方法的一些特殊性质。总之,结论是 EEG 和 MEG 仅部分独立,它们的空间分辨率大致相同。同时记录两者会带来一些关于大脑生物电活动的附加信息。这两种方法具有某些独特的特性,使得它们在某些应用中都有一定的优势。