Fiebach N H, Cook E F, Lee T H, Brand D A, Rouan G W, Weisberg M, Goldman L
Section of General Internal Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut.
Am J Med. 1990 Jul;89(1):15-20. doi: 10.1016/0002-9343(90)90091-q.
To assess whether the admission of patients with chest pain to a stepdown unit would jeopardize the outcome of those patients who ultimately "ruled in" for a myocardial infarction.
We compared the risk of an adverse outcome in initially uncomplicated, "rule-out myocardial infarction" patients who were admitted directly to a stepdown unit (n = 58) or to a coronary care unit (n = 409) at 6 hospitals and who then ultimately "ruled in" for a myocardial infarction.
An adverse outcome (death, serious complication, or invasive intervention) occurred in 16 (28%) stepdown unit patients compared with 159 (39%) coronary care unit patients. Among patients eligible for initial care in either location, the risk of an adverse outcome after controlling for clinical characteristics was similar in the two groups using each of two different multivariate approaches.
Although our study was not of sufficient size to exclude the possibility of a small benefit from initial triage to a coronary care unit, our data suggest that (1) admission of initially uncomplicated chest pain patients with a relatively low probability of acute myocardial infarction to a stepdown unit does not seriously jeopardize those who eventually "rule in" for myocardial infarction; and (2) larger observational or randomized studies, which could reduce the residual possibility of somewhat higher risk in the stepdown unit, would be ethical to perform.
评估将胸痛患者收入降级护理病房是否会危及最终被诊断为心肌梗死的患者的治疗结果。
我们比较了6家医院中最初病情不复杂、“排除心肌梗死”且直接被收入降级护理病房(n = 58)或冠心病监护病房(n = 409),最终被诊断为心肌梗死的患者出现不良结局的风险。
16名(28%)降级护理病房患者出现了不良结局(死亡、严重并发症或侵入性干预),而冠心病监护病房患者中有159名(39%)出现不良结局。在两个病房均可接受初始治疗的患者中,使用两种不同的多变量方法,在控制临床特征后,两组出现不良结局的风险相似。
尽管我们的研究规模不足以排除最初分诊至冠心病监护病房可能带来的微小益处,但我们的数据表明:(1)将急性心肌梗死可能性相对较低、最初病情不复杂的胸痛患者收入降级护理病房,不会严重危及最终被诊断为心肌梗死的患者;(2)开展规模更大的观察性研究或随机研究以降低降级护理病房存在的稍高风险的残余可能性是符合伦理的。