Department of Restorative Dentistry, Leeds Dental Institute, University of Leeds, Worsley Building, Clarendon Way, Leeds, LS2 9LU.
Br Dent J. 2011 Nov 25;211(10):E20. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2011.965.
The objective of this study was to investigate agreement between the estimated remaining dentine thickness (RDT) under lesions of caries, measured from a conventional in vivo periapical radiograph, compared directly to the measured RDT of the tooth. Additional investigation was to be made for agreement between in vitro digital radiographs and conventional radiographs.
This was a cross-sectional, single centre study at Leeds Dental Institute, United Kingdom, in 2009.Subjects, materials and methods Twenty-five carious teeth with occlusal or proximal lesions were collected from patients aged 19 to 82 years attending the Oral Surgery Department. Each patient had a pre-extraction in vivo periapical radiograph of the tooth demonstrating an intact layer of dentine below the lesions of caries. Post-extraction in vitro digital and conventional radiographs were taken.
Agreement of the RDT was analysed using Bland-Altman plots.Results A trend for the radiographic images to over-estimate the RDT compared to the tooth was found. Greater over-estimation of the RDT by conventional radiographs both in vivo and in vitro was shown compared to the in vitro digital images in the majority of cases.
This analysis has demonstrated it is not possible to estimate the dimension of the RDT from a periapical radiograph.
本研究旨在探讨比较牙体硬组织内龋损下剩余牙本质厚度(RDT)的临床常规活体根尖片测量值与直接测量值之间的一致性,同时对体外数字射线照片和常规射线照片之间的一致性进行进一步的研究。
这是 2009 年在英国利兹牙科研究所进行的一项横断面、单中心研究。对象、材料和方法:从年龄在 19 岁至 82 岁之间的口腔外科患者中收集了 25 颗具有咬合面或近中面龋损的患牙。每位患者均在拔牙前拍摄了显示龋损下方有完整牙本质层的牙的活体根尖片。拔牙后拍摄了体外数字射线照片和常规射线照片。
使用 Bland-Altman 图分析 RDT 的一致性。
发现射线照片在测量 RDT 时存在高估趋势,与牙体实际值相比。与体外数字射线照片相比,体内和体外常规射线照片在大多数情况下都显示出对 RDT 的高估程度更大。
该分析表明,从根尖片无法估计 RDT 的尺寸。