INGAR Instituto de Desarrollo y Diseño (CONICET-UTN), S3002GJC Santa Fe, Argentina.
J Environ Manage. 2012 Apr 15;96(1):43-54. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2011.10.014. Epub 2011 Nov 25.
The goal of this work is to research the state-of-the-art in process optimization techniques and tools based on LCA, focused in the process engineering field. A collection of methods, approaches, applications, specific software packages, and insights regarding experiences and progress made in applying the LCA methodology coupled to optimization frameworks is provided, and general trends are identified. The "cradle-to-gate" concept to define the system boundaries is the most used approach in practice, instead of the "cradle-to-grave" approach. Normally, the relationship between inventory data and impact category indicators is linearly expressed by the characterization factors; then, synergic effects of the contaminants are neglected. Among the LCIA methods, the eco-indicator 99, which is based on the endpoint category and the panel method, is the most used in practice. A single environmental impact function, resulting from the aggregation of environmental impacts, is formulated as the environmental objective in most analyzed cases. SimaPro is the most used software for LCA applications in literature analyzed. The multi-objective optimization is the most used approach for dealing with this kind of problems, where the ε-constraint method for generating the Pareto set is the most applied technique. However, a renewed interest in formulating a single economic objective function in optimization frameworks can be observed, favored by the development of life cycle cost software and progress made in assessing costs of environmental externalities. Finally, a trend to deal with multi-period scenarios into integrated LCA-optimization frameworks can be distinguished providing more accurate results upon data availability.
这项工作的目的是研究基于生命周期评价(LCA)的过程优化技术和工具的最新进展,重点关注过程工程领域。本文提供了一套方法、方法、应用、特定的软件包,以及关于在应用 LCA 方法与优化框架相结合方面所取得的经验和进展的见解,并确定了一些总体趋势。在实践中,最常用的方法是“摇篮到大门”概念来定义系统边界,而不是“摇篮到坟墓”概念。通常,特征化因子线性表达清单数据和影响类别指标之间的关系,而忽略污染物的协同效应。在生命周期影响评估方法中,基于终点类别和面板方法的生态指标 99 是实践中最常用的方法。大多数分析案例中,将环境影响的综合作为环境目标,制定单一的环境影响函数。在文献中分析的 LCA 应用中,SimaPro 是最常用的软件。多目标优化是处理此类问题最常用的方法,其中生成帕累托集的ε-约束方法是最常用的技术。然而,人们对在优化框架中制定单一经济目标函数的兴趣有所增加,这得益于生命周期成本软件的发展和对环境外部性成本评估的进展。最后,可以区分出一种处理多期情景的趋势,将其纳入综合 LCA-优化框架中,在数据可用性的情况下提供更准确的结果。