Romeo Umberto, Del Vecchio Alessandro, Capocci Mauro, Maggiore Claudia, Ripari Maurizio
Department of Oral Sciences, (A. Polimeni) University of L'Aquila, L'Aquila, Italy.
Ann Stomatol (Roma). 2010 Jan;1(1):14-8. Epub 2010 Jun 29.
Burning Mouth Syndrome (BMS) is a common disease but still a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge for clinicians. Despite many studies its nature remains obscure and controversial; nowadays there is no consensus about definition, diagnosis and classification. BMS is characterized clinically by burning sensations in the tongue or other oral sites, often without clinical and laboratory findings. According to the etiology, BMS cases should be subdivided into three subtypes: BMS by local factors (lfBMS), BMS by systemic factors (sfBMS) and neurological BMS (nBMS), the most frequent, in which the symptom is caused by central or peripheral neurological malfunctions affecting in particular the taste pathway. To establish the type of BMS, both anamnesis and clinical examination, including laboratory tests, are necessary; nBMS cases will be recognized by exclusion of any other type. In case of lfBMS or sfBMS, the treatment of the main pathology will be resolutive; in nBMS cases many Authors proposed different pharmacological trials without satisfactory results and the current opinion is that a multidisciplinary approach is required to keep the condition under control. This pilot study aimed to investigate whether the biostimulative effect of Low Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) could enhance the symptoms of nBMS cases, improving patients' quality of life.
STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS: Among 160 patients affected by oral burning sensation attending to the Oral Pathology Complex Operative Unit of the Department of Stomatological Sciences of Sapienza University of Rome, 77 resulted affected by nBMS. Twenty-five of these patients, 16 females and 9 males, were randomly selected for low level laser applications. All the patients were irradiated with a double diode laser (Lumix 2 Prodent, Italy) emitting contemporarily at 650 nm and 910 nm, with a fluence of 0.53 J/cm(2) for 15 minutes twice a week for 4 weeks. The areas of irradiation were the sides of the tongue on the path of taste fibers. A NRS (numerical rating scale) evaluation of maximum and minimum pain was registered before and after the treatment. In each case to the total value of NRS rates registered before the treatment was deducted the total NRS rate registered after the treatment. The difference was estimated effective if over two points. The Kruskall-Wallis test revealed the significance of the study (p<0.0001) and the Dunn's Multiple Comparison test, applied to compare NRS rates before and after the treatment, showed that there is not a statistically relevant difference between min NRS ratings before and after treatment, while there are statistically significant differences between max NRS ratings (p<0.05).
All the patients agreed the treatment confirming the general good compliance related to laser treatments. No side effects were registered and all the patients completed the therapy without interruption. Seventeen patients (68%) had relevant benefits from the treatment with valid reduction of NRS ratings. In 8 cases the differences of NRS rates were not relevant being under the limit of reliability established in study design. In no case there was a worsening of the symptoms.
According to the results of this pilot study it is reasonable to suppose that LLLT may play an important role in the management of nBMS cases, more investigations are needed to clarify, by a greater number of cases and a placebo control group, the real effectiveness of this innovative LLLT application.
灼口综合征(BMS)是一种常见疾病,但对临床医生而言,其诊断和治疗仍具挑战性。尽管有诸多研究,但其本质仍不明确且存在争议;目前在定义、诊断和分类方面尚未达成共识。BMS的临床特征是舌部或其他口腔部位有烧灼感,通常无临床及实验室检查异常。根据病因,BMS病例应分为三个亚型:局部因素所致BMS(lfBMS)、全身因素所致BMS(sfBMS)和神经源性BMS(nBMS),其中最常见的是nBMS,其症状由影响味觉通路的中枢或外周神经功能障碍引起。要确定BMS的类型,病史采集和临床检查(包括实验室检查)必不可少;nBMS病例需排除其他类型后方可确诊。对于lfBMS或sfBMS,治疗主要病理状况即可解决问题;对于nBMS病例,许多作者进行了不同的药物试验,但结果并不理想,目前的观点是需要采用多学科方法来控制病情。这项初步研究旨在探讨低强度激光疗法(LLLT)的生物刺激作用是否能改善nBMS病例的症状,提高患者生活质量。
研究设计/材料与方法:在罗马第一大学圣皮耶罗医院口腔科学系口腔病理综合手术单元就诊的160例有口腔烧灼感的患者中,77例被诊断为nBMS。从这些患者中随机选取25例,其中女性16例,男性9例,进行低强度激光治疗。所有患者均接受双二极管激光(意大利Lumix 2 Prodent)照射,该激光同时发射650nm和910nm波长的光,能量密度为0.53J/cm²,每次照射15分钟,每周两次,共4周。照射部位为味觉纤维走行的舌侧。治疗前后采用数字评分量表(NRS)评估最大疼痛和最小疼痛程度。将治疗前记录的NRS评分总值减去治疗后记录的NRS评分总值。若差值超过2分,则认为差异有统计学意义。Kruskal-Wallis检验显示该研究具有显著性(p<0.0001),用于比较治疗前后NRS评分的Dunn多重比较检验表明,治疗前后最小NRS评分无统计学差异,而最大NRS评分有统计学差异(p<0.05)。
所有患者均同意接受治疗,这证实了患者对激光治疗普遍具有良好的依从性。未记录到副作用,所有患者均顺利完成治疗,无中断情况。17例患者(68%)从治疗中获得显著益处,NRS评分有效降低。8例患者的NRS评分差异不显著,低于研究设计中确定的可靠限度。无一例患者症状加重。
根据这项初步研究的结果,有理由推测LLLT可能在nBMS病例的管理中发挥重要作用。需要通过更多病例和安慰剂对照组进行进一步研究,以明确这种创新的LLLT应用的实际效果。