Dhavan Poonam, Bassi Shalini, Stigler Melissa H, Arora Monika, Gupta Vinay K, Perry Cheryl L, Ramakrishnan Lakshmy, Reddy K Srinath
Michael and Susan Dell Center for Healthy Living, University of Texas, School of Public Health, Austin, Texas, USA.
Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2011;12(10):2551-4.
Self-reported tobacco use among young people can underestimate the actual prevalence of tobacco use. Biochemical validation of self-reports is particularly recommended for intervention studies where cessation outcomes are to be measured. Literature on biochemical validation of self-reports of multiple forms of tobacco use in India is sparse, particularly among young people.
The study was conducted during the baseline household survey of a community-based tobacco prevention and cessation intervention trial for youth (10-19 years old) residing in slum communities in Delhi, India in 2009. Salivary cotinine measurement on 1,224 samples showed that youth were under-reporting use of chewing and smoking tobacco.
Self-reports had a low sensitivity (36.3%) and a positive predictive value of 72.6%. No statistically significant difference in under- reporting was found between youth in the control and intervention conditions of the trial, which will be taken into consideration in assessing intervention outcomes at a later time point.
Biochemical validation of self-reported tobacco use should be considered during prevention and cessation studies among youth living in low-income settings in developing countries like India.
The future results of biochemical validation from Project ACTIVITY (Advancing Cessation of Tobacco in Vulnerable Indian Tobacco Consuming Youth) will be useful to design validation studies in resource-poor settings.
年轻人自我报告的烟草使用情况可能低估了实际的烟草使用流行率。对于要测量戒烟结果的干预研究,特别建议对自我报告进行生化验证。关于印度多种形式烟草使用自我报告的生化验证的文献很少,尤其是在年轻人中。
该研究在2009年对居住在印度德里贫民窟社区的10至19岁青少年进行的一项基于社区的烟草预防和戒烟干预试验的基线家庭调查期间进行。对1224份样本进行的唾液可替宁测量表明,青少年低估了咀嚼烟草和吸烟的使用情况。
自我报告的敏感性较低(36.3%),阳性预测值为72.6%。在试验的对照和干预条件下的青少年之间,未发现报告不足的统计学显著差异,这将在以后的时间点评估干预结果时予以考虑。
在印度等发展中国家低收入环境中的青少年预防和戒烟研究中,应考虑对自我报告的烟草使用进行生化验证。
“ACTIVITY项目”(促进印度易患烟草消费青年戒烟)生化验证的未来结果将有助于在资源匮乏地区设计验证研究。