Nurkiewicz Timothy R, Porter Dale W, Hubbs Ann F, Stone Samuel, Moseley Amy M, Cumpston Jared L, Goodwill Adam G, Frisbee Stephanie J, Perrotta Peter L, Brock Robert W, Frisbee Jefferson C, Boegehold Matthew A, Frazer David G, Chen Bean T, Castranova Vincent
The Center for Cardiovascular and Respiratory Sciences, West Virginia University School of Medicine, Morgantown, West Virginia 26506-9105, USA.
Res Rep Health Eff Inst. 2011 Dec(164):3-48.
Pulmonary particulate matter (PM) exposure has been epidemiologically associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality, but the mechanistic foundations for this association are unclear. Exposure to certain types of PM causes changes in the vascular reactivity of several macrovascular segments. However, no studies have focused upon the systemic microcirculation, which is the primary site for the development of peripheral resistance and, typically, the site of origin for numerous pathologies. Ultrafine PM--also referred to as nanoparticles, which are defined as ambient and engineered particles with at least one physical dimension less than 100 nm (Oberdorster et al. 2005)--has been suggested to be more toxic than its larger counterparts by virtue of a larger surface area per unit mass. The purpose of this study was fourfold: (1) determine whether particle size affects the severity of postexposure microvascular dysfunction; (2) characterize alterations in microvascular nitric oxide (NO) production after PM exposure; (3) determine whether alterations in microvascular oxidative stress are associated with NO production, arteriolar dysfunction, or both; and (4) determine whether circulating inflammatory mediators, leukocytes, neurologic mechanisms, or a combination of these play a fundamental role in mediating pulmonary PM exposure and peripheral microvascular dysfunction. To achieve these goals, we created an inhalation chamber that generates stable titanium dioxide (TiO2) aerosols at concentrations up to 20 mg/m3. TiO2 is a well-characterized particle devoid of soluble metals. Sprague Dawley and Fischer 344 (F-344) rats were exposed to fine or nano-TiO2 PM (primary count modes of approximately 710 nm and approximately 100 nm in diameter, respectively) at concentrations of 1.5 to 16 mg/m3 for 4 to 12 hours to produce pulmonary loads of 7 to 150 microg in each rat. Twenty-four hours after pulmonary exposure, the following procedures were performed: the spinotrapezius muscle was prepared for in vivo microscopy, blood samples were taken from an arterial line, and various tissues were harvested for histologic and immunohistochemical analyses. Some rats received a bolus dose of cyclophosphamide 3 days prior to PM exposure to deplete circulating neutrophils and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) was performed in separate groups of rats exposed to identical TiO2 loads. No significant differences in BAL fluid composition based on PM size or load were found in these rats. Plasma levels of interleukin (IL)-2, IL-18, IL-13, and growth-related oncogene (GRO) (also known as keratinocyte-derived-chemokine [KC]) were altered after PM exposure. In rats exposed to fine TiO2, endothelium-dependent arteriolar dilation was significantly decreased, and this dysfunction was robustly augmented in rats exposed to nano-TiO2. This effect was not related to an altered smooth-muscle responsiveness to NO because arterioles in both groups dilated comparably in response to the NO donor sodium nitroprusside (SNP). Endogenous microvascular NO production was similarly decreased after inhalation of either fine or nano-TiO2 in a dose-dependent manner. Microvascular oxidative stress was significantly increased among both exposure groups. Furthermore, treatment with antioxidants (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperdine-N-oxyl [TEMPOL] plus catalase), the myeloperoxidase (MPO) inhibitor 4-aminobenzoic hydrazide (ABAH), or the nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase (NADPH oxidase) inhibitor apocynin partially restored NO production and normalized arteriolar function in both groups. Neutrophil depletion restored dilation in PM-exposed rats by as much as 42%. Coincubation of the spinotrapezius muscle with the fast sodium (Na+) channel antagonist tetrodotoxin (TTX) restored arteriolar dilation by as much as 54%, suggesting that sympathetic neural input may be affected by PM exposure. The results of these experiments indicate that (1) the size of inhaled PM dictates the intensity of systemic microvascular dysfunction; (2) this arteriolar dysfunction is characterized by a decreased bioavailability of endogenous NO; (3) the loss of bioavailable NO after PM exposure is at least partially caused by elevations in local oxidative stress, MPO activity, NADPH oxidase activity, or a combination of these responses; and (4) circulating neutrophils and sympathetic neurogenic mechanisms also appear to be involved in the systemic microvascular dysfunction that follows PM exposure. Taken together, these mechanistic studies support prominent hypotheses that suggest peripheral vascular effects associated with PM exposure are due to the activation of inflammatory mechanisms, neurogenic mechanisms, or both.
流行病学研究表明,肺部暴露于颗粒物(PM)会增加心血管疾病的发病风险和死亡率,但其相关的机制基础尚不清楚。暴露于某些类型的PM会导致多个大血管段的血管反应性发生变化。然而,尚无研究关注体循环微循环,而体循环微循环是外周阻力形成的主要部位,也是众多病理状态的起源部位。超细PM(也称为纳米颗粒,定义为至少有一个物理尺寸小于100 nm的环境颗粒和工程颗粒(Oberdorster等人,2005年))因其单位质量具有更大的表面积,被认为比其较大的对应物毒性更强。本研究的目的有四个:(1)确定颗粒大小是否会影响暴露后微血管功能障碍的严重程度;(2)描述PM暴露后微血管一氧化氮(NO)产生的变化;(3)确定微血管氧化应激的变化是否与NO产生、小动脉功能障碍或两者相关;(4)确定循环炎症介质、白细胞、神经机制或这些因素的组合是否在介导肺部PM暴露和外周微血管功能障碍中起重要作用。为实现这些目标,我们创建了一个吸入室,该吸入室可产生浓度高达20 mg/m³的稳定二氧化钛(TiO₂)气溶胶。TiO₂是一种特性明确的颗粒,不含可溶性金属。将Sprague Dawley和Fischer 344(F-344)大鼠暴露于浓度为1.5至16 mg/m³的细TiO₂或纳米TiO₂ PM(初级计数模式下直径分别约为710 nm和100 nm)中4至12小时,以使每只大鼠肺部的负荷达到7至150 μg。肺部暴露24小时后,进行以下操作:准备斜方肌用于体内显微镜检查,从动脉血管取血样,并采集各种组织用于组织学和免疫组织化学分析。一些大鼠在PM暴露前3天接受大剂量环磷酰胺以耗尽循环中的中性粒细胞,并对暴露于相同TiO₂负荷的不同组大鼠进行支气管肺泡灌洗(BAL)。在这些大鼠中,未发现基于PM大小或负荷的BAL液成分有显著差异。PM暴露后,血浆白细胞介素(IL)-2、IL-18、IL-13和生长相关癌基因(GRO)(也称为角质形成细胞衍生趋化因子[KC])水平发生改变。在暴露于细TiO₂的大鼠中,内皮依赖性小动脉扩张显著降低,而在暴露于纳米TiO₂的大鼠中,这种功能障碍明显加剧。这种效应与平滑肌对NO的反应性改变无关,因为两组的小动脉对NO供体硝普钠(SNP)的反应相似。吸入细TiO₂或纳米TiO₂后,内源性微血管NO产生同样以剂量依赖性方式降低。两个暴露组的微血管氧化应激均显著增加。此外,用抗氧化剂(2,2,6,6-四甲基哌啶-N-氧基[TEMPOL]加过氧化氢酶)、髓过氧化物酶(MPO)抑制剂4-氨基苯甲酸酰肼(ABAH)或烟酰胺腺嘌呤二核苷酸磷酸氧化酶(NADPH氧化酶)抑制剂阿朴色胺处理,可部分恢复两组的NO产生并使小动脉功能正常化。中性粒细胞耗竭使PM暴露大鼠的扩张恢复了多达42%。将斜方肌与快速钠(Na⁺)通道拮抗剂河豚毒素(TTX)共同孵育,使小动脉扩张恢复了多达54%,这表明交感神经输入可能受到PM暴露的影响。这些实验结果表明:(1)吸入PM的大小决定了体循环微血管功能障碍的强度;(2)这种小动脉功能障碍的特征是内源性NO的生物利用度降低;(3)PM暴露后生物可利用NO的丧失至少部分是由局部氧化应激、MPO活性、NADPH氧化酶活性升高或这些反应的组合引起的;(4)循环中的中性粒细胞和交感神经机制似乎也参与了PM暴露后的体循环微血管功能障碍。综上所述,这些机制研究支持了一些重要假设,即与PM暴露相关的外周血管效应是由于炎症机制、神经机制或两者的激活所致。