Sethukavalan Perakaa, Cheung Patrick, Tang Colin I, Quon Harvey, Morton Gerard, Nam Robert, Loblaw Andrew
Odette Cancer Centre, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Can J Urol. 2012 Apr;19(2):6165-9.
To estimate the out-of-pocket costs for patients undergoing external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) for prostate cancer and calculate the patient-related savings of being treated with a 5-fraction versus a standard 39-fraction approach.
Seventy patients accrued to the pHART3 (n = 84) study were analyzed for out-of-pocket patient costs as a result of undergoing treatment. All costs are in Canadian dollars. Using the postal code of the patient's residence, the distance between the hospital and patient home was found using Google Maps. The Canada Revenue Agency automobile allowance rate was then applied to determine the cost per kilometer driven.
The average cost of travel from the hospital and pHART3 patient's residence was $246 per person after five trips. In a standard fractionation regimen, pHART3 patients would have incurred an average cost of $1921 after 39 visits. The patients receiving hypofractionated radiotherapy would have paid an average of $38 in parking while those receiving conventional treatment would have paid $293. The difference in out-of-pocket costs for the patients receiving a standard versus hypofractionated treatment was $1930.
Medium term prospective data shows that hypofractionated radiotherapy is an effective treatment method for localized prostate cancer. Compared to standard EBRT, hypofractionated radiotherapy requires significantly fewer visits. Due to the long distance patients may have to travel to the cancer center and the expense of parking, the short course treatment saves each patient an average of $1900. A randomized study of standard versus hypofractionated accelerated radiotherapy should be conducted to confirm a favorable efficacy and tolerability profile of the shorter fractionation scheme.
评估接受前列腺癌外照射放疗(EBRT)患者的自付费用,并计算采用5次分割方案与标准39次分割方案治疗患者所节省的费用。
对纳入pHART3(n = 84)研究的70例患者进行分析,以确定其治疗后的自付费用。所有费用均以加元计算。利用患者居住地址的邮政编码,通过谷歌地图确定医院与患者住所之间的距离。然后应用加拿大税务局的汽车补贴率来确定每公里的驾车成本。
五次往返后,从医院到pHART3患者住所的平均交通费用为每人246加元。在标准分割方案中,pHART3患者39次就诊后的平均费用为1921加元。接受大分割放疗的患者停车平均费用为38加元,而接受传统治疗的患者停车平均费用为293加元。接受标准治疗与大分割治疗患者的自付费用差值为1930加元。
中期前瞻性数据表明,大分割放疗是局限性前列腺癌的一种有效治疗方法。与标准EBRT相比,大分割放疗所需就诊次数明显更少。由于患者前往癌症中心的路程可能较远以及停车费用较高,短程治疗平均为每位患者节省1900加元。应开展标准放疗与大分割加速放疗的随机研究,以证实较短分割方案具有良好的疗效和耐受性。