Department of Oral Radiology, School of Dentistry, Aarhus University, Vennelyst Boulevard 9, 8000 Aarhus C, Denmark.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2012 Dec;41(8):662-7. doi: 10.1259/dmfr/55922484. Epub 2012 May 3.
To assess changes in facial skin temperature over time, to identify sources of variation related to skin temperature and to evaluate interobserver reproducibility in measurements of the thermograms.
62 volunteers (32 females, 30 males, mean age 23.4, range 19.5-29.5 years) underwent thermography of the face (left and right side lateral images) on four occasions with approximately 2 months between each session. Three observers recorded the images and marked regions of interest (ROIs) in each image using dedicated software. Smoking, exercise habits and use of oral contraceptives were recorded.
A significant difference between sessions (≤1 °C, p<0.001) and between observers (≤0.11 °C, p<0.001) was identified. The difference between sides was not significant (≤0.07 °C, p=0.7). None of the interactions between side, session and observer were significant. Smoking, exercise habits and oral contraceptive intake were not significant impact factors when included as covariates in the analysis (p>0.1). ROI temperature was significantly higher in males than in females (0.7 °C, p<0.001). A mixed model analysis of variance showed that observer had little impact on the expected standard deviation, whereas session and subject had a greater impact.
Face temperature is symmetrical and varies over time. The non-significant difference between sides is highly reproducible, even between observers.
评估面部皮肤温度随时间的变化,确定与皮肤温度相关的变异源,并评估热图测量的观察者间再现性。
62 名志愿者(32 名女性,30 名男性,平均年龄 23.4 岁,范围 19.5-29.5 岁)在大约 2 个月的时间间隔内进行了 4 次面部热成像(左右侧侧图像)。3 名观察者使用专用软件记录图像并在每张图像上标记感兴趣区域(ROI)。记录吸烟、运动习惯和口服避孕药的使用情况。
发现会话之间(≤1°C,p<0.001)和观察者之间(≤0.11°C,p<0.001)存在显著差异。两侧之间的差异不显著(≤0.07°C,p=0.7)。当将侧、会话和观察者之间的相互作用作为协变量纳入分析时,吸烟、运动习惯和口服避孕药的摄入不是显著的影响因素(p>0.1)。男性的 ROI 温度明显高于女性(0.7°C,p<0.001)。方差混合模型分析表明,观察者对预期标准差的影响较小,而会话和受试者的影响较大。
面部温度是对称的,随时间变化。即使在观察者之间,两侧之间的非显著差异也具有高度的可重复性。