Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, University of California Davis, Davis, California, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2012;7(5):e37088. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0037088. Epub 2012 May 15.
The peak in influenza incidence during wintertime in temperate regions represents a longstanding, unresolved scientific question. One hypothesis is that the efficacy of airborne transmission via aerosols is increased at lower humidities and temperatures, conditions that prevail in wintertime. Recent work with a guinea pig model by Lowen et al. indicated that humidity and temperature do modulate airborne influenza virus transmission, and several investigators have interpreted the observed humidity dependence in terms of airborne virus survivability. This interpretation, however, neglects two key observations: the effect of ambient temperature on the viral growth kinetics within the animals, and the strong influence of the background airflow on transmission. Here we provide a comprehensive theoretical framework for assessing the probability of disease transmission via expiratory aerosols between test animals in laboratory conditions. The spread of aerosols emitted from an infected animal is modeled using dispersion theory for a homogeneous turbulent airflow. The concentration and size distribution of the evaporating droplets in the resulting "Gaussian breath plume" are calculated as functions of position, humidity, and temperature. The overall transmission probability is modeled with a combination of the time-dependent viral concentration in the infected animal and the probability of droplet inhalation by the exposed animal downstream. We demonstrate that the breath plume model is broadly consistent with the results of Lowen et al., without invoking airborne virus survivability. The results also suggest that, at least for guinea pigs, variation in viral kinetics within the infected animals is the dominant factor explaining the increased transmission probability observed at lower temperatures.
在温带地区,冬季流感发病率的峰值是一个长期存在但尚未解决的科学问题。一种假设是,在低湿度和低温条件下,通过气溶胶进行空气传播的效果会增强,这种情况在冬季很常见。Lowen 等人最近使用豚鼠模型进行的研究表明,湿度和温度确实会调节空气传播流感病毒的传播,一些研究人员根据观察到的湿度依赖性来解释空气传播病毒的存活率。然而,这种解释忽略了两个关键观察结果:环境温度对动物体内病毒生长动力学的影响,以及背景气流对传播的强烈影响。在这里,我们提供了一个全面的理论框架,用于评估在实验室条件下通过实验动物呼出的气溶胶进行疾病传播的可能性。使用均匀湍流气流的扩散理论来模拟感染动物呼出的气溶胶的传播。在所产生的“高斯呼吸羽流”中,蒸发液滴的浓度和尺寸分布被计算为位置、湿度和温度的函数。整体传输概率是通过感染动物中随时间变化的病毒浓度和暴露动物下游吸入液滴的概率的组合来建模的。我们证明,呼吸羽流模型与 Lowen 等人的结果广泛一致,而无需假设空气传播病毒的存活率。结果还表明,至少对于豚鼠而言,感染动物体内病毒动力学的变化是解释低温下观察到的传输概率增加的主要因素。