Yoder Paul, Fey Marc E, Warren Steven F
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2012 Oct;14(5):410-3. doi: 10.3109/17549507.2012.685890. Epub 2012 May 31.
This commentary suggests that the most commonly studied aspect intensity (dose frequency) on overall rate of response to treatment may often be weak or conditional. To improve statistical power of tests of weak effects additive statistical models have typically been used. However, multiplicative models may be a more productive route to understanding dose frequency effects on children's speech and language development. To illustrate, recent findings are presented that dose frequency effects on vocabulary development varied by two child characteristics. Finally, it is suggested that spacing of teaching episodes within an intervention session be included as a variable in the multi-dimensional model of treatment intensity. Spacing teaching episodes may eventually prove to be one of the more powerful aspects of intensity.
本评论指出,在治疗总体反应率方面,最常研究的强度(剂量频率)方面可能往往作用微弱或具有条件性。为提高对微弱效应检验的统计效力,通常会使用相加统计模型。然而,相乘模型可能是理解剂量频率对儿童言语和语言发展影响的更有效途径。为说明这一点,本文呈现了近期的研究结果,即剂量频率对词汇发展的影响因儿童的两个特征而异。最后,建议将干预疗程内教学环节的间隔作为治疗强度多维模型中的一个变量纳入考量。教学环节的间隔最终可能会被证明是强度方面更具影响力的因素之一。