Yang Shun-nan, Schlieski Tawny, Selmins Brent, Cooper Scott C, Doherty Rina A, Corriveau Philip J, Sheedy James E
Vision Performance Institute, Pacific University College of Optometry, Forest Grove, Oregon 97006, USA.
Optom Vis Sci. 2012 Jul;89(7):1068-80. doi: 10.1097/OPX.0b013e31825da430.
Stereoscopic 3D displays heighten perceived immersion but elevate viewing symptoms for some viewers. The present study measured prevalence and magnitude of perceived immersion and viewing symptoms in stereoscopic viewing, and related them to viewer's characteristics and viewing position.
Two hundred three teens and adults viewed a movie in 2D or 3D while sitting at different angles and distances. Their prior viewing symptoms, as well as visual and physical discomfort immediately before and after viewing, were measured with questionnaires. They were also asked to report their perceived immersion after the viewing.
Twelve percent and twenty-one percent of 2D and stereoscopic 3D participants reported increases of measured symptoms during and/or after viewing. Stereoscopic 3D viewing incurred greater and more frequent perception of blurred vision, double vision, dizziness, disorientation, and nausea than 2D viewing. Reported ocular and physical symptoms were negatively correlated to perceived immersion in 3D viewing. Older viewers (age 46 years or older) reported greater ocular, visual, and motion sickness symptoms in 2D viewing, and younger viewers (age 24-34 years) reported greater visual and motion sickness symptoms in 3D viewing. Sitting in an oblique position attenuated perceived immersion but also reduced motion symptoms in 3D viewing. Prior viewing symptoms in 2D tasks also predicted ocular and physical symptoms in 2D but less so in 3D viewing.
Stereoscopic 3D viewing provides greater immersion, but it can also lead to heightened visual and motion sickness symptoms. Viewers with prior symptoms in viewing TV and computer screen are not more likely to have increased ocular and physical symptoms in 3D viewing. Young viewers incurred higher immersion but also greater visual and motion sickness symptoms in 3D viewing; both will be reduced if a farther distance and a wider viewing angle are adopted.
立体3D显示增强了沉浸感,但会使部分观看者出现观看症状。本研究测量了立体观看中沉浸感和观看症状的发生率及程度,并将它们与观看者的特征和观看位置相关联。
203名青少年和成年人以不同角度和距离坐着观看2D或3D电影。通过问卷测量他们之前的观看症状,以及观看前后的视觉和身体不适。观看后还要求他们报告自己的沉浸感。
2D和立体3D观看者中分别有12%和21%报告在观看期间和/或之后测量到的症状有所增加。与2D观看相比,立体3D观看引起的视力模糊、复视、头晕、迷失方向和恶心的感觉更强烈且更频繁。报告指出,在3D观看中,眼部和身体症状与沉浸感呈负相关。年龄较大的观看者(46岁及以上)在2D观看中报告的眼部、视觉和晕动病症状更严重,而年龄较小的观看者(24 - 3岁)在3D观看中报告的视觉和晕动病症状更严重。在3D观看中,斜着坐会减弱沉浸感,但也会减轻运动症状。2D任务中的先前观看症状也能预测2D中的眼部和身体症状,但在3D观看中预测性较差。
立体3D观看提供了更强的沉浸感,但也可能导致视觉和晕动病症状加剧。在电视和电脑屏幕观看中有先前症状的观看者在3D观看中出现眼部和身体症状增加的可能性并不更高。年轻观看者在3D观看中沉浸感更高,但视觉和晕动病症状也更严重;如果采用更远的距离和更宽的视角,这两种情况都会减轻。