Sellier Elodie, David-Tchouda Sandra, Bal Gaëlle, François Patrice
Unité de qualitique et d'évaluation médicale, CHU Grenoble, Grenoble, France.
Int J Health Care Qual Assur. 2012;25(3):189-96. doi: 10.1108/09526861211210411.
This article aims to analyze morbidity and mortality conferences (M&MCs) in a university-affiliated hospital, notably their format and progression since the 1990s.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: A cross-sectional study was conducted and M&MC characteristics were collected using three methods: a questionnaire to all department heads to identify past M&MCs; semi-structured interviews with each M&MC leader; and when available, meeting reports were analyzed.
Of 189 questionnaires sent to department heads, 105 were completed and returned (55.6 per cent). A total of 27 M&MCs were identified; five times more than in 1994. The M&MC format varied greatly between departments. In surgical units, cases per conference tended to be higher than in intensive care or medical units and paramedical staff were invited less often. Compared with 1998, head nurses (70.4 vs 27.3 percent, p = 0.03) and paramedical staff (63.0 vs 18.2 percent, p = 0.03) attendance increased significantly. Physicians considered M&MCs important for improving service quality, patient safety and enhancing team cohesion.
RESEARCH LIMITATIONS/IMPLICATIONS: Patient outcomes were not assessed.
Although undefined formats allowed leaders to conduct M&MCs according to their objectives, how these conferences are conducted should impact healthcare quality and safety.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: Results indicate that M&MCs have evolved over the past 20 years, showing them to be valuable quality and safety improvement methods.
本文旨在分析一家大学附属医院的发病率和死亡率研讨会(M&MCs),尤其关注其自20世纪90年代以来的形式和发展情况。
设计/方法/途径:进行了一项横断面研究,通过三种方法收集M&MCs的特征:向所有科室主任发放问卷以确定过去的M&MCs;对每个M&MCs的负责人进行半结构化访谈;如有会议报告,则对其进行分析。
向科室主任发放的189份问卷中,105份完成并返回(回复率为55.6%)。共识别出27次M&MCs,是1994年的五倍多。各科室的M&MCs形式差异很大。在外科科室,每次研讨会的病例数往往高于重症监护或内科科室,辅助医疗人员受邀参加的频率较低。与1998年相比,护士长(70.4%对27.3%,p = 0.03)和辅助医疗人员(63.0%对18.2%,p = 0.03)的参会率显著提高。医生们认为M&MCs对提高服务质量、患者安全和增强团队凝聚力很重要。
研究局限性/启示:未评估患者结局。
尽管未明确的形式允许负责人根据自身目标开展M&MCs,但这些研讨会的开展方式应会影响医疗质量和安全。
原创性/价值:结果表明,M&MCs在过去20年中有所发展,显示出它们是有价值的质量和安全改进方法。