Easterbrooks Susan R, Beal-Alvarez Jennifer S
Department of Educational Psychology and Special Education, Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA 30302-3979, USA.
Am Ann Deaf. 2012 Spring;157(1):27-40. doi: 10.1353/aad.2012.1611.
Historically, researchers have identified that reading outcomes for students in upper grades who are d/Deaf and hard of hearing (d/Dhh) have typically rested around the late 3rd to early 4th grade. In recent years, wide-scale state-level testing has called into question these prognostications. The authors conducted a descriptive, multiunit, embedded-designs case study of 7 states' data from multiyear annual assessments of reading of participants in grades 3, 5, and 8, and in high school. Participants, states' definitions of reading outcomes, and states' reported reading results are described. The authors, who found that many students are reading at levels above the perceived 3rd-to-4th-grade "glass ceiling," build the case for a more hopeful look at reading outcomes for these students than that of the past and recommend approaches for acquiring wide-scale data that will allow professionals in the field to better understand reading outcomes in this population.
从历史上看,研究人员已经确定,高年级失聪和听力障碍(d/Dhh)学生的阅读成绩通常停留在三年级末到四年级初的水平。近年来,大规模的州级测试对这些预测提出了质疑。作者对7个州三年级、五年级、八年级和高中参与者多年阅读年度评估的数据进行了描述性、多单元、嵌入式设计的案例研究。描述了参与者、各州对阅读成绩的定义以及各州报告的阅读结果。作者发现,许多学生的阅读水平高于人们所认为的三到四年级的“玻璃天花板”,他们提出理由,认为与过去相比,应该更乐观地看待这些学生的阅读成绩,并推荐获取大规模数据的方法,以便该领域的专业人员更好地了解这一人群的阅读成绩。