New York University Child Study Center, NY, USA. gudino.omar@gmail
Psychiatr Serv. 2012 Oct;63(10):1004-10. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201100427.
This study examined racial disparities in mental health service use by problem type (internalizing versus externalizing) for youths in contact with the child welfare system.
Participants included 1,693 non-Hispanic white, African-American, and Hispanic youths (ages four to 14) from the National Survey of Child and Adolescent Well-Being, a national probability study of youths who were the subject of investigations of maltreatment by child welfare agencies. Mental health need, assessed at baseline, was considered present if the youth had internalizing or externalizing scores in the clinical range on either the Child Behavior Checklist or the Youth Self-Report. Out patient mental health service use in the subsequent year was assessed prospectively.
Children who were removed from the home and those investigated for abuse (versus neglect) were more likely to receive services in the year after the child welfare investigation. Overall, African-American youths were less likely than non-Hispanic white youths to receive mental health services. However, race-ethnicity moderated the association between externalizing need and service use such that African Americans were more likely to receive services when externalizing need was present (26% versus 4%) compared with non-Hispanic white youths (30% versus 14%). Race and ethnicity did not moderate the association between youth internalizing need and service use, but internalizing need was associated with increased probability of service use only for non-Hispanic white youths.
Examinations of overall racial disparities in service use may obscure important problem specific disparities. Additional research is needed to identify factors that lead to disparities and to develop strategies for reducing them.
本研究考察了儿童福利系统接触的青少年的心理健康服务利用在问题类型(内在问题与外在问题)上的种族差异。
参与者包括来自全国儿童和青少年福利调查的 1693 名非西班牙裔白人、非裔美国人和西班牙裔青少年(年龄在 4 至 14 岁之间),这是一项对因受虐待而被儿童福利机构调查的青少年的全国概率研究。心理健康需求是根据基线评估的,如果青少年在儿童行为检查表或青少年自我报告上的内在或外在得分处于临床范围内,则认为存在心理健康需求。随后一年的门诊心理健康服务使用情况是前瞻性评估的。
被带离家庭的儿童和因虐待(而非忽视)而受到调查的儿童在儿童福利调查后的一年中更有可能获得服务。总体而言,非裔美国青少年获得心理健康服务的可能性低于非西班牙裔白人青少年。然而,种族和民族身份调节了外在需求与服务利用之间的关联,使得非裔美国人在存在外在需求时更有可能获得服务(26%比 4%),而非西班牙裔白人青少年(30%比 14%)。种族和民族身份并没有调节青少年内在需求与服务利用之间的关联,但内在需求仅与非西班牙裔白人青少年获得服务的可能性增加有关。
对服务利用总体种族差异的检查可能会掩盖重要的特定问题的差异。需要进一步研究以确定导致差异的因素,并制定减少差异的策略。