Overwaal, Centre for Anxiety Disorders, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Eur J Psychotraumatol. 2010;1. doi: 10.3402/ejpt.v1i0.5626. Epub 2010 Dec 6.
Despite the strong empirical support for the effectiveness of exposure-based treatments in ameliorating post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), improvement of treatment is wanted given relatively high dropout rates and challenges of treating patients with high comorbidity and treatment-interfering stressors. The purpose of the current paper is to introduce an intensive exposure treatment program, illustrated by four case descriptions of PTSD patients, who suffered multiple (sexual) traumas in childhood, had high levels of comorbidity and psychosocial stressors, and failed to improve during "regular" trauma-focused treatment programs. The program consisted of psychoeducation, prolonged imaginal exposure, exposure in vivo, exposure by drawings combined with narrative reconstructing, and writing assignments about central trauma-related cognitions. The treatment included 5 working days with individual sessions (in total 30 h of treatment) provided by a team of four therapists. The PTSD symptoms of all patients decreased substantially and the effect sizes were large (Cohen's d resp. 1.5 [pre-post], 2.4 [pre-FU1 month], and 2.3 [pre-FU3 months]). Also, none of the patients showed symptom worsening or dropped out. The evaluation of these four pilot cases suggests that it is possible to intensify exposure treatment, even for multiple traumatized PTSD patients with high comorbidity. We concluded that the first results of this new, intensive exposure program for PTSD patients with childhood sexual abuse are promising.
尽管暴露疗法在改善创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)方面具有强有力的经验支持,但鉴于较高的脱落率以及治疗合并症较多和存在治疗干扰因素的患者的挑战,仍需要改进治疗方法。本文的目的是介绍一种强化暴露治疗方案,通过 4 名 PTSD 患者的案例描述来说明,这些患者在童年时期遭受过多次(性)创伤,合并症和心理社会应激源水平较高,且在“常规”以创伤为中心的治疗方案中无法改善。该方案包括心理教育、长时间的想象暴露、现场暴露、结合叙事重构的绘画暴露和与核心创伤相关认知有关的写作作业。治疗包括由 4 名治疗师组成的团队提供 5 个工作日的个体治疗(共 30 小时的治疗)。所有患者的 PTSD 症状均显著减轻,效应量较大(Cohen's d 分别为 1.5 [治疗前-后]、2.4 [治疗前-1 个月随访]和 2.3 [治疗前-3 个月随访])。此外,没有患者出现症状恶化或脱落。对这 4 个试点案例的评估表明,即使对于合并症较多的遭受过多次创伤的 PTSD 患者,也有可能强化暴露治疗。我们得出结论,这种新的针对遭受过儿童期性虐待的 PTSD 患者的强化暴露治疗方案的初步结果是有希望的。