Department of Pharmacology, Zagreb University School of Medicine, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia.
Med Teach. 2012;34(12):1056-63. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2012.716180. Epub 2012 Aug 30.
Reports on effects of advancing medical education on health anxiety are scarce and contradictory.
To evaluate a hypothesis that its components could be differently affected.
A cross-sectional study assessed the Health Anxiety Questionnaire (HAQ), Anxious Thoughts Inventory, and Somatosensory Amplification Scale scores in medical (n = 214) and law (controls, n = 821) students at different study years.
In the controls, all outcomes minimally differed across the study-year levels. Medical scores were similar to control scores at the lower and intermediate level and were significantly lower at higher study years. However, health worry, fear, and reassurance seeking only differed mildly between the medical study levels (adjusted effect sizes ≤ 0.23), whereas tendency toward amplification, meta-worry, social worry, and the HAQ interference with life score were significantly lower at higher than at the lower years (adjusted effect sizes 0.31-0.47). In the medical students, the HAQ interference with life score was affected mainly by the level of meta-worry, whereas in controls the major impact was that of health-related concerns.
Studying medicine does not seem to relevantly affect the level of health-related concerns, but the degree by which they are perceived as disruptive declines as a specific function of advancing stages of education. This is closely related to progressively declining tendency toward amplification and levels of meta-worry.
关于医学教育进展对健康焦虑影响的报告很少且相互矛盾。
评估一个假设,即其组成部分可能受到不同的影响。
一项横断面研究评估了医学(n=214)和法律(对照组,n=821)学生在不同学习年限的健康焦虑问卷(HAQ)、焦虑思维量表和躯体感觉放大量表评分。
在对照组中,所有结果在学习年限水平上差异极小。医学分数与较低和中等水平的对照组分数相似,在较高的学习年限时显著较低。然而,健康担忧、恐惧和寻求安慰仅在医学学习水平之间略有差异(调整后的效应大小≤0.23),而倾向于放大、元担忧、社会担忧和 HAQ 对生活的干扰在较高的学习年限显著低于较低的学习年限(调整后的效应大小为 0.31-0.47)。在医学学生中,HAQ 对生活的干扰主要受元担忧程度的影响,而在对照组中,主要影响是与健康相关的担忧。
学习医学似乎不会显著影响与健康相关的担忧程度,但随着教育阶段的推进,它们被认为具有干扰性的程度会下降。这与躯体感觉放大倾向和元担忧水平的逐渐下降密切相关。