Tissue Viability Department, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, Leeds, UK.
J Tissue Viability. 2012 Nov;21(4):105-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jtv.2012.08.002. Epub 2012 Sep 10.
This paper explores the issues faced by research nurses in pressure ulcer research through reflection on our own practice and subsequently addresses these issues through critical appraisal of the existing literature.
A critical reflection framework which provided an opportunity for group reflection and reflexivity was adopted to guide our reflection. Focus questions were formulated based on our reflections and used to inform our literature review. Keywords used in the literature review search included 'research nurse', ethical principles, ethical issues and reflection. A formal tool was used to appraise normative ethics articles.
Reflection on our practice in pressure ulcer research identified four main issues: informed consent, confidentiality, methodological uncertainties and more generally the ethical dilemma of the conflict between our accountability and responsibility to the patients and obligations to the research studies. The notion of 'power relations' was found to permeate our practice as research nurses at all level. Six normative ethics papers were retrieved and critically appraised to aid our personal and professional learning and development in the conduct of ethical practice as research nurses in pressure ulcer research through the theory of practice which other research nurses and/or nurse researchers used in other disciplines.
Four main ethical challenges and the issue of power relation were highlighted. Our reflection and the appraisal of the literature provided us the necessary knowledge and skills to better navigate these ethical challenges in the future.
本文通过对研究护士在压疮研究中所面临的问题进行反思,探讨了这些问题,并通过对现有文献的批判性评价来解决这些问题。
采用批判性反思框架,为小组反思和反思提供机会,指导我们的反思。根据我们的反思,制定了焦点问题,并用于指导文献综述。文献综述搜索中使用的关键词包括“研究护士”、“伦理原则”、“伦理问题”和“反思”。使用正式工具对规范伦理文章进行评估。
对压疮研究实践的反思确定了四个主要问题:知情同意、保密、方法学不确定性以及更普遍的冲突问题,即我们对患者的问责制和责任与对研究的义务之间的冲突。作为研究护士,我们在各级实践中都发现了“权力关系”的概念。检索并批判性评价了六篇规范伦理论文,以帮助我们在压疮研究中作为研究护士进行伦理实践的个人和专业学习与发展,这是其他研究护士和/或护士研究人员在其他学科中使用的实践理论。
突出了四个主要的伦理挑战和权力关系问题。我们的反思和文献评价为我们提供了必要的知识和技能,以便在未来更好地应对这些伦理挑战。