Key Laboratory of Behavioral Science, Institute of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China.
PLoS One. 2012;7(10):e46922. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0046922. Epub 2012 Oct 8.
Orthographic neighborhood size (N size) effect in Chinese character naming has been studied in adults. In the present study, we aimed to explore the developmental characteristics of Chinese N size effect. One hundred and seventeen students (40 from the 3(rd) grade with mean age of 9 years; 40 from the 5(th) grade with mean age of 11 years; 37 from the 7(th) grade with mean age of 13 years) were recruited in the study. A naming task of Chinese characters was adopted to elucidate N-size- effect development. Reaction times and error rates were recorded. Results showed that children in the 3(rd) grade named characters from large neighborhoods faster than named those from small neighborhoods, revealing a facilitatory N size effect; the 5(th) graders showed null N size effect; while the 7(th) graders showed an inhibitory N size effect, with longer reaction times for the characters from large neighborhoods than for those from small neighborhoods. The change from facilitation to inhibition of neighborhood size effect across grades suggested the transition from broadly tuned to finely tuned lexical representation in reading development, and the possible inhibition from higher frequency neighbors for higher graders.
中文命名的正字法邻近效应(N 效应)在成人中已有研究。本研究旨在探索中文 N 效应的发展特点。我们招募了 117 名学生(三年级 40 名,平均年龄 9 岁;五年级 40 名,平均年龄 11 岁;七年级 37 名,平均年龄 13 岁)。采用汉字命名任务来阐明 N 效应的发展。记录反应时间和错误率。结果表明,三年级学生从大邻域命名字符比从小邻域命名字符更快,表现出促进性的 N 效应;五年级学生则表现出中性的 N 效应;而七年级学生则表现出抑制性的 N 效应,即从大邻域命名字符的反应时间比从小邻域命名字符的反应时间长。年级间从促进到抑制邻域大小效应的变化表明,阅读发展中从广泛调谐到精细调谐的词汇表征的转变,以及高年级学生可能受到更高频率邻居的抑制。