Lee Eun-Jung, Ra Young-Shin
Department of Neurosurgery, Asan Medical Center, College of Medicine, University of Ulsan, Seoul, Korea.
J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2012 Oct;52(4):325-33. doi: 10.3340/jkns.2012.52.4.325. Epub 2012 Oct 22.
The indications and optimal surgical treatments for intracranial cysts are controversial. In the present study, we describe long-term clinical and neuroimaging results of surgically treated intracranial cysts in children. The goal of this study is to contribute to the discussion of the debate.
This study included 110 pediatric patients that underwent surgeries to treat intracranial cysts. Endoscopic cyst fenestrations were performed in 71 cases, while craniotomies and cyst excisions (with or without fenestrations) were performed in 30 patients. Cystoperitoneal shunts were necessary for nine patients. Long-term results were retrospectively assessed with medical and neuroimaging records.
Clinical and radiological improvement was reported in 87.3% and 92.8% of cases, respectively, after endoscopic neurosurgery, and in 93.3% and 100% using open microsurgery whereas 88.9% and 85.7% after shunt operation. There were no statistical differences in clinical outcomes (p=0.710) or volume reductions (p=0.177) among the different surgeries. There were no mortalities or permanent morbidities, but complications such as shunt malfunctions, infections, and subdural hematomas were observed in 56% of the patients that had shunt operations. A total of 13 patients (11.8%) underwent additional surgeries due to recurrences or treatment failures. The type of surgery performed did not influence the recurrence rate (p=0.662) or the failure rate (p=0.247).
Endoscopic neurosurgeries are less invasive than microsurgeries and are at least as effective as open surgeries. Thus, given the advantages and complications of these surgical techniques, we suggest that endoscopic fenestration should be the first treatment attempted in children with intracranial cysts.
颅内囊肿的适应证及最佳手术治疗方法存在争议。在本研究中,我们描述了手术治疗儿童颅内囊肿的长期临床和神经影像学结果。本研究的目的是为这场争论的讨论提供参考。
本研究纳入了110例行手术治疗颅内囊肿的儿科患者。71例行内镜下囊肿开窗术,30例行开颅囊肿切除术(有或无开窗)。9例患者需要行囊肿-腹腔分流术。通过医学和神经影像学记录对长期结果进行回顾性评估。
内镜神经外科手术后,分别有87.3%和92.8%的病例临床和影像学得到改善;开颅显微手术后分别为93.3%和100%;分流手术后分别为88.9%和85.7%。不同手术方式的临床结局(p=0.710)或体积缩小情况(p=0.177)无统计学差异。无死亡或永久性致残情况,但在接受分流手术的患者中观察到56%出现分流故障、感染和硬膜下血肿等并发症。共有13例患者(11.8%)因复发或治疗失败接受了二次手术。所施行的手术类型不影响复发率(p=0.662)或失败率(p=0.247)。
内镜神经外科手术的侵入性小于显微手术,且至少与开放手术一样有效。因此鉴于这些手术技术的优缺点,我们建议内镜开窗术应作为儿童颅内囊肿的首选治疗方法。