Glenngård Anna H, Hjelmgren Jonas, Thomsen Per Hove, Tvedten Torbjörn
The Swedish Institute for Health Economics (IHE) , Lund , Sweden.
Nord J Psychiatry. 2013 Oct;67(5):351-9. doi: 10.3109/08039488.2012.748825. Epub 2012 Dec 17.
The choice between different attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) medications depends on different drug attributes. Economic evaluations of drugs often disregard the utility of other attributes compare with the drugs' efficacy.
The aim of this study was to assess patient's preferences and elicit willingness-to-pay (WTP) for different drug attributes in the treatment of ADHD.
285 patients (117 parents for children below 15 years, 52 adolescents 15-17 years and 116 adults aged 18 years and above) from Sweden, Denmark and Norway completed a questionnaire concerning their ADHD drug treatment, and answered questions on their preferences using a discrete choice experiment (DCE). Included attributes were effectiveness, side-effects, dosing and price.
Effectiveness was the most important attribute, followed by side-effects and the number of dosings per day (all P < 0.001). The estimated monthly WTP for a drug generating full effectiveness, no side-effects and once-daily dosing was €790 for adolescents and €360 for adults. The estimated WTP for ADHD drugs with characteristics similar to existing drugs on the market was higher or in line with market prices (€37-180 for adolescents and €16-80 for adults). Regarding experience with current treatment, 19% of all patients in the study reported good functioning during the morning, day and evening.
The gap between the monetary valuation of existing products and an optimally valued product suggest that there is room for improvements in the clinical management of ADHD. The results suggest that DCE is a method that can be used to value not only hypothetical scenarios but also can be used to value and distinguish between real-life scenarios.
不同的注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)药物之间的选择取决于不同的药物属性。药物的经济评估通常忽视了与药物疗效相比其他属性的效用。
本研究的目的是评估患者对ADHD治疗中不同药物属性的偏好,并引出支付意愿(WTP)。
来自瑞典、丹麦和挪威的285名患者(117名15岁以下儿童的家长、52名15 - 17岁的青少年和116名18岁及以上的成年人)完成了一份关于他们ADHD药物治疗的问卷,并使用离散选择实验(DCE)回答了关于他们偏好的问题。纳入的属性包括有效性、副作用、给药频率和价格。
有效性是最重要的属性,其次是副作用和每日给药次数(所有P < 0.001)。对于一种产生完全有效性、无副作用且每日给药一次的药物,青少年的估计每月支付意愿为790欧元,成年人的估计每月支付意愿为360欧元。具有与市场上现有药物相似特征的ADHD药物的估计支付意愿高于或符合市场价格(青少年为37 - 180欧元,成年人16 - 80欧元)。关于当前治疗的体验,研究中所有患者的19%报告在早晨、白天和晚上功能良好。
现有产品的货币估值与最优估值产品之间的差距表明ADHD的临床管理仍有改进空间。结果表明,离散选择实验不仅是一种可用于评估假设情景,还可用于评估和区分现实生活情景的方法。