Ankolekar Sandeep, Renton Cheryl, Sprigg Nikola, Bath Philip M W
Stroke Trials Unit, Division of Stroke, University of Nottingham, City Hospital Campus, Nottingham NG5 1PB, UK.
Stroke Res Treat. 2013;2013:562506. doi: 10.1155/2013/562506. Epub 2013 Mar 26.
Background. Assessing poststroke cognitive impairment is complex. A subscale of the NIHSS, the Cog-4, has been proposed as a quick test of "cognitive impairment." but a study of its properties in a larger dataset is lacking. Methods. Data from 9,147 patients with acute stroke from the VISTA archive was used to generate Cog-4 scores. The statistical properties of Cog-4, its relationship with baseline clinical characteristics, and other functional outcome measures at day 90 were assessed. Results. Mean age of patients was 69.2 years and 45.8%, were females. Day-90 Cog-4 was highly positively skewed (skewness 0.926). Patients with left hemispheric stroke had higher day-90 Cog-4 score (P < 0.001). Age, stroke severity, and previous stroke were significant predictors of Cog-4. Cog-4 was significantly correlated with dependency (modified Rankin Scale, r s = 0.512), and disability (Barthel Index, r s = -0.493). Conclusions. The Cog-4 scale at day 90 cannot be considered a useful test of cognition since it only superficially measures cognition. It is heavily dependent on the side of stroke, is inevitably associated with functional outcome (being a subset of the NIHSS), and suffers from a profound "floor" effect. Specific and validated measures are more appropriate for the assessment of poststroke cognition than Cog-4.
背景。评估卒中后认知障碍很复杂。美国国立卫生研究院卒中量表(NIHSS)的一个子量表Cog-4,已被提议作为一种“认知障碍”的快速检测方法,但缺乏在更大数据集上对其特性的研究。方法。使用来自VISTA档案库的9147例急性卒中患者的数据来生成Cog-4评分。评估了Cog-4的统计特性、其与基线临床特征的关系以及90天时的其他功能结局指标。结果。患者的平均年龄为69.2岁,45.8%为女性。90天时的Cog-4呈高度正偏态(偏度为0.926)。左半球卒中患者90天时的Cog-4评分更高(P<0.001)。年龄、卒中严重程度和既往卒中是Cog-4的显著预测因素。Cog-4与依赖程度(改良Rankin量表,rs=0.512)和残疾程度(Barthel指数,rs=-0.493)显著相关。结论。90天时的Cog-4量表不能被视为一种有用的认知检测方法,因为它只是表面地测量认知。它严重依赖于卒中的部位,不可避免地与功能结局相关(作为NIHSS的一个子量表),并且存在严重的“地板效应”。对于卒中后认知的评估,特异性且经过验证的测量方法比Cog-4更合适。