内科住院医师连续性诊所重新设计为 50/50 门诊/住院模式的评估。
An evaluation of internal medicine residency continuity clinic redesign to a 50/50 outpatient-inpatient model.
机构信息
Division of Primary Care Internal Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
出版信息
J Gen Intern Med. 2013 Aug;28(8):1014-9. doi: 10.1007/s11606-012-2312-1.
BACKGROUND
There have been recent calls for improved internal medicine outpatient training, yet assessment of clinical and educational variables within existing models is lacking.
OBJECTIVE
To assess the impact of clinic redesign from a traditional weekly clinic model to a 50/50 outpatient-inpatient model on clinical and educational outcomes.
DESIGN
Pre-intervention and post-intervention study intervals, comparing the 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 academic years.
PARTICIPANTS
Ninety-six residents in a Primary Care Internal Medicine site of a large academic internal medicine residency program who provide care for > 13,000 patients.
INTERVENTION
Continuity clinic redesign from a traditional weekly clinic model to a 50/50 model characterized by 50 % outpatient and 50 % inpatient experiences scheduled in alternating 1 month blocks, with twice weekly continuity clinic during outpatient months and no clinic during inpatient months.
MAIN MEASURES
- Clinical outcomes (panel size, patient visits, adherence with chronic disease and preventive service guidelines, continuity of care, patient satisfaction, and perceived safety/teamwork in clinic); 2) Educational outcomes (attendance at teaching conference, resident and faculty satisfaction, faculty assessment of resident clinic performance, and residents' perceived preparedness for outpatient management).
RESULTS
Redesign was associated with increased mean panel size (120 vs. 137.6; p ≤ 0.001), decreased continuity of care (63 % vs. 48 % from provider perspective; 61 % vs. 51 % from patient perspective; p ≤ 0.001 for both; team continuity was preserved), decreased missed appointments (12.5 % vs. 10.9 %; p ≤ 0.01), improved perceived safety and teamwork (3.6 vs. 4.1 on 5-point scale; p ≤ 0.001), improved mean teaching conference attendance (57.1 vs. 64.4; p ≤ 0.001), improved resident clinic performance (3.6 vs. 3.9 on 5-point scale; p ≤ 0.001), and little change in other outcomes.
CONCLUSION
Although this model requires further study in other settings, these results suggest that a 50/50 model may allow residents to manage more patients while enhancing the climate of teamwork and safety in the continuity clinic, compared to traditional models. Future work should explore ways to preserve continuity of care within this model.
背景
最近有人呼吁加强内科门诊培训,但对现有模式中的临床和教育变量进行评估的情况却很少。
目的
评估从传统的每周门诊模式转变为 50/50 门诊-住院模式对临床和教育结果的影响。
设计
在干预前和干预后两个时间段进行比较,比较 2009-2010 学年和 2010-2011 学年。
参与者
96 名来自大型内科住院医师实习计划的基层医疗内科实习基地的住院医师,他们为超过 13000 名患者提供医疗服务。
干预措施
连续性诊所设计从传统的每周诊所模式转变为 50/50 模式,50%的门诊和 50%的住院经验安排在 1 个月的交替块中,在门诊月份每周进行两次连续性诊所,而在住院月份没有诊所。
主要观察指标
1)临床结果(患者人数、就诊次数、慢性病和预防服务指南的依从性、连续护理、患者满意度、以及诊所的安全性/团队合作感知);2)教育结果(参加教学会议、住院医师和教师满意度、教师对住院医师诊所表现的评估,以及住院医师对门诊管理的准备情况)。
结果
设计转变与平均患者人数的增加(从 120 增加到 137.6;p≤0.001)、连续护理的下降(从提供者的角度看,从 63%下降到 48%;从患者的角度看,从 61%下降到 51%;p≤0.001;团队连续性得以保留)、错过预约的减少(从 12.5%下降到 10.9%;p≤0.01)、感知安全性和团队合作的提高(5 分制上从 3.6 分提高到 4.1 分;p≤0.001)、教学会议出席率的提高(从 57.1%提高到 64.4%;p≤0.001)、住院医师诊所表现的提高(从 3.6 分提高到 3.9 分;p≤0.001),其他结果变化不大。
结论
尽管这种模式在其他环境中需要进一步研究,但这些结果表明,与传统模式相比,50/50 模式可能允许住院医师在连续性诊所中管理更多的患者,同时增强团队合作和安全性的氛围。未来的工作应该探索在这种模式下保持连续护理的方法。