Department of Psychophysiology at National Institute of Mental Health, and Integrative Brain Imaging Center, National Center of Neurology and Psychiatry, 4-1-1 Ogawahigashi, Kodaira, Tokyo 187-0031, Japan.
Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2014 May;9(5):591-600. doi: 10.1093/scan/nst030. Epub 2013 Apr 17.
People believe that women are more emotionally intense than men, but the scientific evidence is equivocal. In this study, we tested the novel hypothesis that men and women differ in the neural correlates of affective experience, rather than in the intensity of neural activity, with women being more internally (interoceptively) focused and men being more externally (visually) focused. Adult men (n = 17) and women (n = 17) completed a functional magnetic resonance imaging study while viewing affectively potent images and rating their moment-to-moment feelings of subjective arousal. We found that men and women do not differ overall in their intensity of moment-to-moment affective experiences when viewing evocative images, but instead, as predicted, women showed a greater association between the momentary arousal ratings and neural responses in the anterior insula cortex, which represents bodily sensations, whereas men showed stronger correlations between their momentary arousal ratings and neural responses in the visual cortex. Men also showed enhanced functional connectivity between the dorsal anterior insula cortex and the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, which constitutes the circuitry involved with regulating shifts of attention to the world. These results demonstrate that the same affective experience is realized differently in different people, such that women's feelings are relatively more self-focused, whereas men's feelings are relatively more world-focused.
人们认为女性比男性更情绪化,但科学证据尚无定论。在这项研究中,我们检验了一个新的假设,即男性和女性在情感体验的神经相关性上存在差异,而不是在神经活动的强度上存在差异,女性更注重内部(内感受),而男性更注重外部(视觉)。我们招募了 17 名成年男性和 17 名成年女性,让他们在观看有强烈情感感染力的图片的同时完成功能磁共振成像研究,并对他们的主观唤醒的即时感受进行评分。我们发现,当观看唤起情绪的图片时,男性和女性在情感体验的强度上并没有总体差异,但正如我们所预测的那样,女性在前脑岛皮层的神经反应和瞬间唤醒评分之间显示出更强的相关性,前脑岛皮层代表身体感觉,而男性在前脑岛皮层和视觉皮层的神经反应和瞬间唤醒评分之间显示出更强的相关性。男性在前脑岛背侧和前扣带皮质的功能连接也更强,这构成了调节注意力向世界转移的相关回路。这些结果表明,同样的情感体验在不同的人身上表现不同,女性的感受相对更自我关注,而男性的感受相对更关注外部世界。