Hayreh S S, Klugman M R, Beri M, Kimura A E, Podhajsky P
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Iowa, Iowa City 52242.
Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 1990;228(3):201-17. doi: 10.1007/BF00920022.
We investigated prospectively in 128 patients (140 eyes) the role of six routine clinical tests in the differentiation of ischemic central retinal vein occlusion (CRVO) from non-ischemic CRVO during its early acute phase. There were four functional tests [visual acuity, visual fields, relative afferent pupillary defect (RAPD), electroretinography (ERG)] and two morphologic tests (ophthalmoscopy and fluorescein fundus angiography). We found that none of the six tests had 100% sensitivity and specificity in such a differentiation during the early, acute phase, so that no one test can be considered a "gold standard"; however, combined information from all six is almost always reliable. Overall, the four functional tests proved far superior to the two morphologic tests in differentiating ischemic from non-ischemic CRVO:RAPD was most reliable in uniocular CRVO (with a normal fellow eye), followed closely by ERG in all cases; combined information from RAPD and ERG differentiated 97% of cases; perimetry was the next most reliable, followed by visual acuity. The two morphologic tests performed worst; fluorescein angiography provided either no information at all on retinal capillary nonperfusion (in at least one-third of the eyes during the early, acute phase) because of multiple limitations, or sometimes provided misleading information. Ophthalmoscopic appearance is the least reliable, most misleading parameter.
我们前瞻性地研究了128例患者(140只眼)在缺血性视网膜中央静脉阻塞(CRVO)早期急性期,六项常规临床检查在鉴别缺血性CRVO和非缺血性CRVO中的作用。其中包括四项功能检查[视力、视野、相对传入性瞳孔障碍(RAPD)、视网膜电图(ERG)]和两项形态学检查(检眼镜检查和荧光素眼底血管造影)。我们发现,在早期急性期,这六项检查中没有一项在这种鉴别中具有100%的敏感性和特异性,因此没有一项检查可以被视为“金标准”;然而,来自所有六项检查的综合信息几乎总是可靠的。总体而言,在鉴别缺血性和非缺血性CRVO方面,四项功能检查远优于两项形态学检查:RAPD在单眼CRVO(健眼正常)中最可靠,其次是ERG在所有病例中;RAPD和ERG的综合信息可鉴别97%的病例;视野检查其次最可靠,然后是视力。两项形态学检查表现最差;荧光素血管造影由于多种限制,要么在视网膜毛细血管无灌注方面根本不提供任何信息(在早期急性期至少三分之一的眼中),要么有时提供误导性信息。检眼镜外观是最不可靠、最具误导性的参数。