McInerney Michael J, Fink L Dee
Department of Botany and Microbiology, 770 Van Vleet Oval and.
Microbiol Educ. 2003 May;4:3-12. doi: 10.1128/me.4.1.3-12.2003.
We used team-based learning to improve comprehension and critical thinking of students in an undergraduate microbial metabolism-physiology course. The course used well-known bacterial pathways to highlight themes of energy conservation and biodegradation. Prior to the introduction of team-based learning, student recall of this information was poor and students had difficulty extrapolating information to new organisms. Initially, individual and group quizzes were added to promote problem-solving and critical-thinking skills. This significantly improved student attitudes about the amount of information they learned and whether the instructor promoted critical thinking. However, retention of the material as judged by final examination scores was still poor. In the next year, two challenging projects were added to the course to complement the above themes: (i) postulating a pathway for the metabolism of a substrate by a bacterium, and (ii) modifying the current model for anaerobic sulfate reduction by incorporating recent genetic information. The inclusion of the team projects significantly improved final examination scores compared to the previous year without team projects. Overall, team-based learning with challenging projects improved the students' comprehension and retention of information, critical thinking, and attitudes about the course and focused student-instructor interactions on learning rather than grades.
我们采用基于团队的学习方法,以提高本科微生物代谢生理学课程中学生的理解能力和批判性思维。该课程利用著名的细菌代谢途径来突出能量守恒和生物降解的主题。在引入基于团队的学习之前,学生对这些信息的记忆很差,并且难以将信息推广到新的生物体。最初,增加了个人和小组测验以培养解决问题和批判性思维能力。这显著改善了学生对所学信息量以及教师是否促进批判性思维的态度。然而,根据期末考试成绩判断,材料的留存率仍然很低。在接下来的一年,课程中增加了两个具有挑战性的项目以补充上述主题:(i)推测一种细菌对底物的代谢途径,以及(ii)通过纳入最新的遗传信息来修改当前的厌氧硫酸盐还原模型。与上一年没有团队项目相比,团队项目的纳入显著提高了期末考试成绩。总体而言,带有挑战性项目的基于团队的学习提高了学生对信息的理解和留存率、批判性思维,以及对课程的态度,并使学生与教师的互动集中在学习而非成绩上。