Kamal R, Natrajan M, Katoch K, Arora M
National JALMA Institute for Leprosy & Other Mycobacterial Diseases (ICMR), Agra-282001, India.
Indian J Lepr. 2012 Oct-Dec;84(4):287-306.
This study reports detailed analysis of clinical parameters and clearance of granuloma in borderline leprosy patients treated with immunotherapy and chemotherapy. It aims to assess the additive effect of immunotherapy (Mwvaccine) with standard MDT on clinical status of untreated borderline leprosy cases and on granuloma fraction of untreated borderline leprosy cases. Patients attending the OPD were serially recruited in two groups. A total of 150 cases in one treatment (trial) group (Mw vaccine plus MDT) and 120 cases in another treatment (control) group (MDT only) of border line leprosy have been included. After the formal written consent, detailed clinical examination, charting, smear examination of all untreated borderline patients of both groups was done, biopsies were taken from the active lesions of all patients of both groups at start of therapy and every six month thereafter till the completion of therapy. The same procedure was repeated every six months during the follow-up period. Standard MDT was given to all the patients of both groups according to type of disease. Mw vaccine 0.1 ml (0.5 x 10(9) bacilli) was injected intra-dermally at the start of therapy and every six months in addition to chemotherapy to the treatment group. The BT cases were followed up after 6 doses of MDT and 2 doses of Mw vaccine, and, the BB, BL cases were followed up after 24 doses of MDT plus 5 doses of Mw vaccine. Clinically, greater and faster improvement was observed in all the clinical parameters, faster attainment of smear negativity and two episodes of lepra reaction occurred in cases treated with combined chemotherapy and immunotherapy, as compared to controls (chemotherapy alone) wherein clinical improvement was slower in all parameters, slower attainment of smear negativity in bacillary index and seven showed the occurrence of reactions, histipathologically in addition to more rapid clearance of granuloma in immunotherapy treated group, a significant finding was an increase in the epithelioid cells population in this group. This suggests a possible immunoactivation of the macrophages especially in BB/BL immunotherapy group. Overall comparison of regression induced by chemotherapy alone with that induced by combined chemotherapy and immunotherapy shows a greater reduction in clinical parameters as well as granuloma fraction in BT cases as well as in BB/BL cases. This trial shows the potential usefulness of this approach of addition of immunotherapy to standard chemotherapy in borderline leprosy cases which leads to in faster recovery from disease reduced chances of reactions and faster granuloma clearance. Such information is expected to be useful in improving the immunotherapeutic approaches for treatinggranulomatous conditions in general and in leprosy in particular.
本研究报告了对接受免疫疗法和化疗的界线类麻风患者临床参数及肉芽肿清除情况的详细分析。其目的是评估免疫疗法(Mw疫苗)与标准多药联合化疗(MDT)对未经治疗的界线类麻风病例临床状况及未经治疗的界线类麻风病例肉芽肿比例的附加作用。在门诊就诊的患者被连续招募入两个组。界线类麻风的一个治疗(试验)组共150例(Mw疫苗加MDT),另一个治疗(对照)组共120例(仅MDT)。在获得正式书面同意后,对两组所有未经治疗的界线类患者进行了详细的临床检查、记录、涂片检查,在治疗开始时及此后每6个月从两组所有患者的活动性病变处取材活检,直至治疗结束。在随访期间每6个月重复相同程序。根据疾病类型对两组所有患者给予标准MDT。治疗组在治疗开始时及每6个月除化疗外,皮内注射0.1 ml Mw疫苗(0.5×10⁹杆菌)。BT病例在接受6剂MDT和2剂Mw疫苗后进行随访,BB、BL病例在接受24剂MDT加5剂Mw疫苗后进行随访。临床上,与对照组(仅化疗)相比,联合化疗和免疫疗法治疗的病例在所有临床参数上改善更大、更快,更快实现涂片阴性,且发生了两例麻风反应,而对照组在所有参数上临床改善较慢,细菌指数涂片阴性实现较慢,有7例出现反应。组织病理学上,除免疫疗法治疗组肉芽肿清除更快外,一个重要发现是该组上皮样细胞数量增加。这表明巨噬细胞可能被免疫激活,尤其是在BB/BL免疫疗法组。单独化疗诱导的消退与联合化疗和免疫疗法诱导的消退的总体比较显示,BT病例以及BB/BL病例在临床参数和肉芽肿比例方面降低幅度更大。该试验表明在界线类麻风病例中,在标准化疗基础上加用免疫疗法这种方法具有潜在效用,可使疾病恢复更快、反应机会减少且肉芽肿清除更快。预计此类信息将有助于改进一般肉芽肿性疾病尤其是麻风的免疫治疗方法。