Prabhakar A R, Manojkumar A Jaiswal, Basappa N
Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, Bapuji Dental College and Hospital, Davangere, Karnataka, India.
J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2013 Jan-Mar;31(1):29-35. doi: 10.4103/0970-4388.112403.
Currently, fluoride is the most effective preventive treatment for remineralization of incipient carious lesions and dentinal hypersensitivity due to wasting disorders. The products containing fluoride, calcium and phosphate are also claim to remineralize early, non-cavitated enamel demineralization. The aim of this study was to investigate and compare the efficacy of two such products, Tooth Mousse and Clinpro tooth crème on remineralization and tubule occluding ability with 5000ppm fluoride-containing toothpaste.
Thirty third molar teeth were placed in demineralizing solution for 5 days such that only a window of 1mm x 5mm was exposed to the environment to produce artificial caries-like lesions and randomly assigned to three groups: Group I, 5000ppm sodium fluoride; Group II, GC MI paste plus and Group III, Clinpro tooth crème. Axial longitudinal sections of 140-160 μm of each tooth which included the artificial carious lesion taken and were photographed under polarized light microscope. The demineralized areas were then quantified with a computerized imaging system. The experimental materials were applied onto the tooth sections as a topical coating and subjected to pH-cycling for 28 days. To evaluate tubule occlusion ability, thirty dentin specimens of 2mm thickness were obtained from cervical third of sound third molars. Specimens were ultrasonicated and etched with 6% citric acid for 2 minutes to simulate the hypersensitive dentin. Specimens were randomly divided into above mentioned three groups (n=10). The test agents were brushed over the specimens with an electric toothbrush, prepared and observed under Scanning Electron Microscope for calculation of the percentage of occluded tubules.
Group I showed a significantly greater percentage of remineralization than Group III and Group II. Comparison of the remineralization potential between group II and group III were not significant.In case of dentine hypersensitivity, Group I and group III showed greater percentage of tubule occlusion ability than Group II. Intergroup comparison of the tubule occlusion potential of group I and group III were not significant.
Within the limitations of our study, sodium fluoride showed relatively greatest remineralizing and dentinal tubule occlusion property when compared with GC MI paste plus and Clinpro tooth crème.
目前,氟化物是对早期龋损再矿化以及因消耗性疾病导致的牙本质过敏最有效的预防性治疗方法。含有氟化物、钙和磷酸盐的产品也宣称可使早期、非龋洞性釉质脱矿再矿化。本研究的目的是调查并比较两种此类产品——齿优嘉(Tooth Mousse)和Clinpro牙齿护理霜与含5000ppm氟化物的牙膏在再矿化和小管封闭能力方面的效果。
将30颗第三磨牙置于脱矿溶液中5天,仅使1mm×5mm的窗口暴露于环境中以产生人工龋样病变,然后随机分为三组:第一组,5000ppm氟化钠;第二组,GC MI糊剂加;第三组,Clinpro牙齿护理霜。从每颗牙齿切取包含人工龋损的140 - 160μm轴向纵切片,并在偏光显微镜下拍照。然后用计算机成像系统对脱矿区域进行定量分析。将实验材料作为局部涂层涂覆在牙齿切片上,并进行28天的pH循环处理。为评估小管封闭能力,从健康第三磨牙的颈部三分之一处获取30个厚度为2mm的牙本质标本。将标本超声处理并用6%柠檬酸蚀刻2分钟以模拟过敏牙本质。标本随机分为上述三组(n = 10)。用电动牙刷将测试剂刷涂在标本上,制备后在扫描电子显微镜下观察,计算封闭小管的百分比。
第一组的再矿化百分比显著高于第三组和第二组。第二组和第三组之间再矿化潜力的比较无显著差异。在牙本质过敏方面,第一组和第三组的小管封闭能力百分比高于第二组。第一组和第三组之间小管封闭潜力的组间比较无显著差异。
在我们研究范围的限制内,与GC MI糊剂加和Clinpro牙齿护理霜相比,氟化钠显示出相对最大的再矿化和牙本质小管封闭特性。